Friday, 14 November 2014

Monty Pythonesque

I wrote a post in response to a comment that people who smoke should be required to pay for their own medical and hospital care.

I provided the colossal figures to illustrate how smokers and drinkers and lottery ticket hopefuls not only pay for their own hospital and medical care, they probably pay the better part of everyone else's  as well.

Then I get a  how-dare -you comment. Accusing me of  stating  smokers,drinkers and lottery ticket holders should have to pay for their own hospital and medical costs.

The writer points out how much revenue comes from smokers et al and how the Province could not make it up elsewhere. And concludes  in his/her surprise that a person with the liberal stance I proclaim could suggest medical and hospital care should be denied to people who smoke.

I am repeating the argument because it is such a perfect illustration of how a supremely  self-righteous person,can twist the reality to suit her/his preformed preference.

The optimum opportunity presents itself  in writing only occasionally.

Since the blog belongs to me It seems only fair that  I should  make use of it to establish the reality is Monty Python's Circus.

4 comments:

  1. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I once watched a funny exchange between 2 customers at the grocery store. A woman buying a handful of lottery tickets went after a man getting cigarettes. Each said the other was wasting money.
    They were both holding up the check-out line.

    ReplyDelete
  4. According to the Ontario Ministry of Finance the following revenue figures are part of the 2014 Budget:

    In hundreds of millions of dollars -

    Tobacco 1,300
    Beer and Wine 572
    OLGC - Lottery 2,053
    LCBO 1,779 5,704

    Gas Tax 2,395
    Fuel Tax 734 3,129

    Total provincial revenue is shown as 118,870,000,000

    The "sin" tax revenue equals 4.8% of revenue, gas and fuel equals 2.6 %.

    I'm not sure what lies buried in the budget so trying to get an accurate picture is probably impossible, which is typical of government budgets in general

    ReplyDelete

If you've got a comment, this is the place to leave it for me. Please feel free to leave your name, or even just an email address if you'd like a response. You can also email me directly.