"Cowardice asks the question...is it safe? Expediency asks the question...is it politic? Vanity asks the question...is it popular? But conscience asks the question...is it right? And there comes a time when one must take a position that is neither safe, nor politic, nor popular but one must take it because it is right." ~Dr. Martin Luther King

Thursday, 16 January 2014

That's an excuse not an argument

Anonymous has left a new comment on your post "Last Call Gentlemen Please":

I really wish I thought you were right, Evelyn. But I can't agree. There may be opportunities there but it is awfully late for reversals. 

**********
It's the beauty of the democratic process. We have a right to disagree.

If we are making a decision on behalf of the community, we have na obligation to provide 
an argument to support it. 

Being too late to  reverse a decision not yet made is not a valid argument. 

It is not an argument at all. 

It's a lame exc
Council  can not be more confident that the  current estimate of $19 million dollars is  any more firm than the original of $14.5 million or the immediately previous of $24 million. 

A hospital in Niagara Region has this week been approved by the Province at a cost of $26 million .

Think about that.

The current  works and  parks sites  are still in public ownership.

The bylaw required by  provincial legislation, to declare the property surplus has not been passed. 

There's more to be said . And I will say it.  But right now, I need to have breakfast.

Last Call Gentlemen Please

Anonymous has left a new comment on your post "Out of
Confusion.....Clarity ????":

I read with interest in the Auroran about how badly Aurora needed to do the
Heritage purchase & all the reasons that the opportunity should not be
missed. The proponent was not one of the property owners. It was our own
head of staff. Can't recall ever voting for the man who I don't think even
lives in Aurora. I, on the other hand, am very familiar with the properties
in question, one of which has been rejected by the market for about 2
decades.


**********************

I do not know that the above statement is true. 

I do know Mr Albino  appeared as leading proponent with a real estate operator hard on his heels. 

The Historical  Society  was used in the process. 

The  Mayor lent  his  Office in support. 

The Report  to Council on Tueday is signed by the CAO. 

Written  by a Special Project Planner  subject to direction of the CAO.

A consultant study has been produced .Funding for same is in question. 

I am   not persuade to merit in the report .

Real estate speculation is  not the  role of  a Municipality .

Taxation on people's homes and business cannot be considered a source of risk capital. 

When Council  approved an  updated  Strategic, the decision  did not .could not  authorise staff to implement in a  myriad direction to make the vision
To take that meaning is to demonstrate failure to understand the basic principles of elective authority.

Strategic  Plan visions are excessive and language unbelievably juvenile. 

I cringe at reference to the  goal of   " an exceptional quality of life for all"

The right of people to choose  decision-makers is inviolate. 

I  believe  intent  of  members is to be the best they can be. 

The mandate ends in nine months. 

Time yet to demonstrate growth in competence and confidence. 

Immediately pending  decisions provide opportunity. 

First being the go-ahead for a Joint facility for Works and Parks to be constructed on a shelf  built out on the side of a ravine requiring massive retaining walls at a cost of millions to make  a poorly chosen site suitable  for the purpose . 

The  roject is as  sound and stable as the site is not. 

A review  and termination of  a lease to the federal government of a  town-owned site and building would  negate the need  for $ millions of excessive spending.

Little current use  of the facility  by the tenant is observed 

There's more . .. much more

The budget process provides .  Opportunities abound.

It's  alast chance.







Wednesday, 15 January 2014

Out of Confusion.....Clarity ????

I chaired the general committee meeting last night.

A couple of contradictions were corrected.

The  agenda of the in-camera meeting  prior to the Committee meeting  listing acquisition of Yonge Street property,  was not the same acquisition  of property listed in the agenda of  the in-camera meeting held after the  general committee meeting.

In fact, the first acquisition was not even Yonge Street properties. Apparently I missed a second brown envelope containing the agenda of the Special Council meeting held to authorize the first in-camera meeting to happen.

And apparently the meeting was not held to authorize acquisition of properties that are not really on Yonge Street.

What we did was authorize staff to keep tabs on something  cooking between the Province and the post-secondary academic community.

That's all I can tell you about that .

The 107 page report , on the cockamamie heritage theme park , aka  by me as a real estate scam ,that was first item of the agenda of the general committee meeting .was received for information, to be dealt with at a general committee meeting a month from now.

Dismay was noted by some Councillors about how authority was conveyed for this work to be done
and the report presented.

No doubt all well be revealed.

But the word is, Council is not on the edge of parting with  massive chunks out of the Hydro Asset Reserve Fund to  convey to a couple of property-owners for  creation of a Heritage theme park.

The report should be at the Library for anyone who wants to read it.

It's called the Hillary-McIntyre Park  Cost Benefit Study   ..Report CAO 14-001



The one that got away

Stirring the porridge , a picture flashed through my mind of a summer afternoon at the Sandbanks.

We were making our way to the beach ,adults in front,small ones  following. We stopped  at a T-intersection and  I looked back to check the entourage.

Four little cousins  strolled quietly, hand in hand gazing here and there and upwards. The ten and seven year old  sisters on either side,four year old twins in the middle.

We were at the bottom of an incline. No-one else around. It was quiet and peaceful.

The trees towered above ....brambles and wild flowers clustered at the edge. Four-legged,furry creatures  also silently shared the space close to the ground

The small figures were diminished further by the breadth and  height of their surroundings.

In bathing suits and flip-flops ,they were part of the nature surrounding them.

I didn't have a camera. I never have a camera.

It will always be the picture, that can never be re-captured ,that I really minded not taking.


Tuesday, 14 January 2014

Smoke and Mirrors and Barbecue Sauce

Years ago, when Sterling Drug was  located in Aurora, there was a union strike that went on for some time.

The town was less than ten thousand. Most of the employees were Aurora residents.

The Aurora Banner  sought anddained an interview with a management spokesperson.

I remember a  quote from the story , only one, but it stands out stark and clear in my memory.

 The VIP told the newspaper;  "We could teach monkeys to do what they do"

I thought; " whatever you have learned mister, you have acquired  no judgement whatsoever.

Comments  on remuneration yesterday were interesting.

I  think judgement is an essential quality of management. It's what we pay for. If it's not there, we are not getting value .

A comment  suggests to  determine he going rate for the job  is how to decide on appropriate remuneration is to

It's  the constant measurement used.

On Saturday's budget discussion it was noted the IT department had asked for a  trainer position. The request was denied. Suggestion made t seek to share a  trainer with  the Town of Newmarket.

At an OMA conference a couple  of years ago,I attended  a  workshop on the Work Asset
Management  System aka WAMS.

Municipalities in Ontario are having  considerable difficulty implementing the system.

In November 2011, Aurora bought a  WAMS software program at a cost of $440,000. The IT department were neither consulted nor informed.

The next audit produced a management letter indicating  problems in the treasury department linked to a lack of training and direction for hands on staff.

Since the system was purchased  additional bits and pieces  have been purchased. Council really doesn't know the final tally.

The budget advises of the merits of hand-held devices . Another likely future purchase.

As near as I can determine, field employees are having to come in earlier to input into the computer  the  daily record of tasks accomplished .

It's what  the Work Asset Management  System is about.

Hardly surprising  many municipalities are having difficulty with the concept.They can't all afford to spend  money on a consultant to recommend the purchase of a $440,000 soft-ware program and wait two years for it to  be "up and running"

Ontario has 440 municipalities. Not all  GTA. Not all collecting billions in extortion money from builders of homes and  spending willy-nilly on luxuries and toys  and airy-fairy entrepreneur schemes never dreamed of  when  it was clear and transparent who was footing the bill.

And poor judgement  in decision-making  was equally conspicuous .

Aurora shares fire protection services with the Town of Newmarket. Our water system is connected.

The transit system is Regional.

The Northern Six municipalities  contract garbage collection and insurance coverage.

Now it's suggested  an IT trainer  might be shared with the Town of Newmarket.

Consultants are retained to tell us what to do next and eliminate a position  to save money. Which was promptly done without time to turn around.

So who is accountable?

Did the devil make us do it?

We shift  department responsibilities in  consultant-led   re-organisation  and when it doesn't work, we shift them again.

We take out  membership in a Canadian Institute of Excellence  then we apply for a Bronze Certificate  to  cover ourselves in glory and tell the   nation know how great we art.

In the meantime  good employees are thrown away  like they were so much flotsam.

I hear  at the present time ,Management Team meetings are attended by a conciliator to help the team get along.




A Low Point

It's 4.23a.m.

I am not sleeping.

I've been carrying a great weight inside of me since Saturday morning.

It's always worse in the night.

 I have nowhere to go with it. I need to share.

A comment notes  I weave a marvelous web.   I suppose, if  a story is told , as it happens, it  could be perceived as a web woven strand by strand until it's complete.

On Saturday morning ,before the budget meeting started, I learned I  had  been powerless to prevent  two decisions  which by my standards were  merciless and unjust.

An employee of twenty-six years service  was displaced by  a decision to eliminate her position . I sought  an explanation  and was informed  that would be micro-managing.

On Saturday, I learned of a second position eliminated. Council made the decision  this time. The employee was informed a week before Christmas.

The tasks remain.  Cost  still needs to be borne.

It's hard to reconcile the decisions with an argument for economic efficiency. There is none.

Even harder to justify  the devastation to a loyal  and conscientious employee.

The  cold,  grey heartlessness that countered my concern ... the lack of empathy around me ...was certainly an assault on my consciousness.

Experts have determined all decisions  are based on 80% emotion and 20% logic.

What emotion  was involved in the  two decisions?

It certainly wasn't compassion

Or  even simple humanity.

How  were eight people , Mayor and seven Councillors influenced by a single emotion?

I had no stomach to join  the group  on Saturday for budget discussion.

 I did anyway.

I did so again last night.

I will again  to-night.

In a $75 million dollar budget I  argued  against membership in an Institute for Excellence ...competing to be one of a hundred best  employers in Canada. 

And  against  an $8,000 grant to the Chamber of Commerce for Business Achievement Awards;
framed paper certificates presented to  businesses lucky enough to survive, presented at a  gala dinner which may or may not be held within the municipality. 

And against $8,500 to advertise  in a commercial  sports magazine ,

Trivial amounts to be sure. 

Symbols  nonetheless , of  a perception  that's not really true.

We are a small town ....eighty-five thousand souls.

We elect a Council of nine  to serve the community's interest.

At  the very least we  should expect no harm to come of  it.

Monday, 13 January 2014

Only One Thing Is Known

The  position of Director of Corporate and  Legislative Services has been eliminated by Council. 

The Municipal clerk who holds the position is still  working . He was at the Budget meeting on Saturday and will be there again to-night.

 He presented the  department's 2014 budget and everyone at the table knew what they had done. 

The responsibilities of the position are still  there. 

It's not clear how they will be carried out without the Director in place.

I have yet to discover that. 

A conundrum.

I can't  publish comments  that reflect  negatively on staff.

 I  don't want to edit comments.

Comments that add to reader understanding of  municipal business  are  particularly welcome.

I have a problem when I receive an informative comment that reflects negatively on staff.

Would you  please send the 2012 list of salaries over $100.000. again without editorial comment

It would really be appreciated

Thank you ,whoever you are.

Airy Fairy ,,,Peter Pan ....Tinker Bell....Lost Boys

The idea for the theme park appeared to  have originated  with the Historical Society.

In these modern Aurora times , one learns not to depend on appearances. Scratching the surface, frequently reveals a plan within a plan ....a strategy leading to a strategy.

Aurora Historical Society recently celebrated  its fifty year anniversary.I have been around  and been a supporter from the beginning .

Half a century is a period in history.

I returned to Council in 2003.  The Society had been raising funds. The old school had been gutted with hundreds of  volunteer hours....collection in storage... curator in Hillary House.

A retired School Board Director was retained adviser for school renovations.

Sharon Nisbett was a feisty and determined President.

$750,000,  had been raised ...  future of  the museum was firm.

The building was always to accommodate museum and cultural events.

Legal Counsel was retained  and an agreement  struck  with the town to protect the Society's investment in a building they did not own.

After three years,  the building,  with millions already invested in structural restoration,stood  idle, empty and costing.

Hydro was sold and realized a substantial asset.  That decision was compelled by the Province.

I moved, Ron Wallace seconded and Council approved ,funding to complete a state of the art museum Eventually it  cost $2.3 million and was completed during the next term of office.

The  Society had commissioned  and paid for the  design.

Society president changed ,The group withdrew commitment to operate the museum.They were too few . They had fifty-nine members. The agreement was set aside. The museum never came to be...until now.

A horrendously expensive agreement to purchase culture took its place.

Fast forward...another new president. Organization numbers slightly over a hundred.  Structure of executive slightly fuzzy.

Volunteers  for fund-raising events are frequently sparse. Failure to muster half the membership at the last  annual meeting meant a plan to change the name was abandoned.

A new member , William Albino, joined. An executive within the executive ,including Society President, was suddenly functional. From there, like computer generated artifice, the idea of a heritage theme park  was preseted to the board and then introduced to the community as the idea of the Historical Society.

A list of prominent activists were solicited to lend their names, Mayor Dawe among them to lend their support.

Persistent  manipulation  and calculation  has proceeded since and up to the current position of recommended the land be assembled.

From where I sit , there is no substance to the  scheme.

$25,000 of taxpayers money has been spent on a consultant, despite  te initial decision of Council was for proponents to make that investment .

Proponents include two property owners , one a real estate operator one a member of the Historical Society, who stand to make in excess of a million dollars apiece if the town agrees to purchase the properties

There's a pattern here.

I think  we have a number of  would-be Warren Buffet's  squashed together in a tight closet in Hillary House yearning to  make the Swan's leap in the ballet of that name, into centre stage of the election.

Oh My Goodness.








.










Transparency...I think not.

Anonymous has left a new comment on your post "Noe so blind as those who will not see....":


Section 228 on the Municipal Act (1) states that "A municipality shall appoint a clerk whose duty it is,"........... and (2) "A municipality may appoint deputy clerks."............and (3) A clerk or deputy clerk is not required to be an employee of the municipality."

One should also read sections (a) - (e) of Section 228 (1) to see just what a clerk's duties are.

Now we have no clerk - I assume 
who was terminated - so what steps has the town taken to replace him as without such a person no minutes of the proceedings of council can be recorded. Is this all going to be on streaming?

The actions that seem to have occurred in the past few months have demonstrated a Council completely lacking in any capacity to think clearly and thus its decisions are not only suspect but downright stupid and over the top expensive. And I don't want to hear any more dribble from the Treasurer about all our contingency funds and our ability to borrow unlimited amounts of money at bargain basement interest rates. Who in their right mind is going to buy a Town of Aurora debt instrument? Certainly not I.

If an election were to be held next week, following the publication of this Council's recent activities, I doubt if very many would be re-elected.

"His Honour" should more aptly be referred to as "Gold-fingers." 


***************************

The   comment  is relevant.

 A clerk  has many responsibilities under the law. 

A deputy clerk  is certified and  may be Acting -Clerk. It means the function of  Town  Clerk is  still  essential. 

The Town clerk is also Elections Officer. 

This is an election year. In September Council becomes a lame duck. 

Already  candidates are registering. Preparations for an election takes months.

If the clerk is mandator the election officer , how can there be an elections officer without a clerk.

Employment separation do not come without a price .

Severance packages are normal and fair,

Twenty- six years of  public service commitment certainly merits a substantial package. How could elimination of  that employment possibly represent financial efficiency.

In the last several years ,severances  must have amounted to  substantial expenditure .

Never have I seen a line item identified in any budget document .

I attended the last two meetings  of the year held before Christmas. I  sought deferral of the CAO's confidential  memorandum to Council. It was deferred.

I missed the  last Council meeting in 2013 .

The minutes of the last  Council meeting have not  yet been distributed.

The Service Level  Consultant Study was scheduled to be presented in December.  I will not know  how Council decided  which, if any, Director position should be eliminated.

I saw nothing in the media.

I was not asked for comment.

I will not know how....when .... or why Council made the  decision until I receive the minutes.

Perhaps not even then.





Sunday, 12 January 2014

Clarification.

Litigation between  myself  and six defendants is still in process. No decision has been made.

The case will proceed  in due time.




Noe so blind as those who will not see....

Anonymous has left a new comment on your post "Neither fish, nor fowl. nor good red herring":

Too many concerns about resources to fund all the projects on the books. No worries, Aurora taxpayers have bags of money. Tax increases are easy. This Mayor and his sidekick (Abel)will need more when these projects go to construction. Lets call it another tax hike to support the future.

Where else can you find a gold plated building to park the Town's dump trucks and snowplows? The truck mechanics best wear business suits to keep up the image.


************

A chart  presented to Council at budget time  notes the  high education and income of Aurora residents.

Staff reports advise Council residents expect  high  service levels to be maintained.

A current sercice level report adopted by Council in December notes  cos of services are among the highest in Ontario. Bradford , used as a comparator, is higher.

Bradford ,recently amalgamated with  the Township of West  Gwillimbury is in no  respect a comparator.

The consensus of contributors to the report, mainly staff is  that our costs are higher because our serice levels are higher.

 Nothing in the report identifies a higher level of service to support the contention.

Recreational programs are excellent but they earn revenue that ore than cover the cost..

The consultant suggested a way of reducing costs; eliminate a director's position.

Yesterday ,prior to the budget seesion, I  learned Council  accepted  a recomendation to eliminate 

the position of  Town Clerk. A statutory office.

The decision was  communicated  to the official a week before Christmas.

Of course, you are only hearing  about it now. No doubt it was another one of those items not called for discussion.



Another recent decision saw elimination ofa cerk's osition in the treasury department

A town employee with twenty-six years  service was displaced right  out the door.

The word seeped out and Councillors were informed  by the Mayor the issue was none of our business.
They are on the agenda....open and transparent....but if they;re not called for discussion you  hear nothing about it.

Despite  peculiarly precise advice  to reduce cost of services by eliminating a director's position, the
public work's  2014 budget  increased  costs more than the savings  by recommending five new positions

Three part-time seasonal  employees. One contract position . A supervisory position to cost $75,000 in 2 014, rising  to $105,000 in 2016 .

The Director  informed  Council he is unabe  to cope with the "gap"   in management.

The  supervisory position  was  deleted by a  Coucil vote  of five to four.

Nevertheless,  despite  layers of scrutiny  the recommndation did  reach Council.

Four Councillors , Abel, Thompson .Ballard and Pirri were persuaded.

Damage and other costs of the ice storm  have  not yet ben calculated and added to the  budget.

As noteed by the Chief Financial Officer,  the storm happened in  2013.

Another small idiosyncracy of budgeting in Aurora and for all I know,  in other municipalities, maybe even the Region, cost of road maintenance  iscalculated  on a per capita basis . Not by kilometre.  

Cost to maintain fifty-five  kilometres of road  would  show a  hundred times less by  using population  figures  of fifty-five thousand  as opposed to lineage of roads.

Aurora is a paid -up member of  an Ottawa Institute of Excellence. 

There was excitement  when  we learned  this year,  the town  had made the hundred runners- up  list in the race to  beat  out  all other  Canadian member municipalities .

As employer of  a twenty-six year  town employee , tossed out in the name of organizational efficiency, without as much as a by my leave, I am  singularly unimpressed by the level of excellence
achieved.

I felt compelled to inform  His Honour  yesterday, I am not much influenced by a remote connection to an Ottawa Institute  of Excellence.

For all I know ,it might only have a hundred and one members.

I have a ring side seat in Aurora.


Sunday Morning Backdrop

Her name is Maeva Evelyn Buck. Isn't that nice?

It's Sunday morning.  My thoughts are dancing  forward in a dozen different directions.

The day stretches ahead and I am free  .

To communicate whatever occurs...

In whatever order.

 I thought of future  generations  of  my family and what they might learn  from archives of the founding generation. J  am not being  entirely fanciful.

The comments were made. They are a matter of record. I was also described as archaic and having been around too long.

I  am the first woman elected to the office of Mayor in Aurora.  First to be elected to a second term.   First  to be elected and serve  for twenty five years and  still going.

I may be first  bag-lady to walk  town streets  courtesy of  resources of  the people who  chose  me  repeatedly to  represent their interest. 

My story is a chronicle of  the age of a generation of politicians who don't  believe they should be criticized.

They think it's new and I am its author.

The only  thing  new is social media.

Criticism is  an occupational hazard of politrics.  It has  and will always be  an essential exchange.

The forum  used to be the Chinese restaurant , often the only one,  on Main Street of every  community  in Ontario.

Gossip didn't wait  for  the  weekly newspaper. It was lively, electric and instantaneous.

Someone was always happy to relay the most salacious item to the person in office, particularly the Mayor

The conventional wisdom of the day :  " If you can;t stand the heat. stay out of the kitchen."

A second :  "Perception is the reality"

It was wise to be aware and note THE perception.

Not wise to offer a public display of  thin skin and indignation .

Politics is an arena in every sense of the word.

Social media is only a new tool in the practice thereoff.

Becoming  less new all the time.






Balderdash...Poppycock...Etcetera...Etcetra....

Anonymous has left a new comment on your post "Neither fish, nor fowl. nor good red herring":

To 12:15

N.B. 'our' versus 'mine' - this visionary concept will be for generations of Aurorans to enjoy...even the petty, small-minded ones.


*******************

We will examine the source of this "visionary concept" later .

The week that was

Isla Buck had a first  birthday just days ago and a new baby-sister  yesterday at 2.24 p.m. I was at a town budget meeting when she arrived. She didn't have a name as of last night. She is the eigth grat-grandchild of the  fourth generation Canadian , counting my own, in my familt and my great grand-daughter.

If her  great-grandchild ever decides to research the family history may she  read  the founding mother of the Canadian family was a liar, a schemer, cared only about herself ,was all about insinuation and innuendo and  was motivated entirely by greed.

 I believe she might. And of course, I will not be here to re-assure her.

What can I do to prevent her from believing .  Or keep it from damaging  her  own future in  whatever career path she might choose?

The oldest member of her generation was promoted in the sea cadets this week. Cheyenne is eleven years old alreay and following in Aunt Stephanie's foot steps. 

Stephanie went to summer  training in bases in Halifax and Vancouver , rose through the ranks, was flwon to Ottawa to shadow the Lord High Admiral for a day and on the  last summer was an instructor at Kingston  before she was eighteen years old. 

Her Uncle Patrick, a  mural artist in Ottawa is in Thai Land  at the moment.  He was in Paris in summer and loves being an uncle. He will be looking forward to  meeting the newest member  of the family. We missed seeing him at Christmas because of the ice storm.

Eighteen  year old  cousin Robyn was named employee of the year at the Manor , the Catering Club House in Kettleby.

So far ,we have six girls and two boys  and  among them a set of twins in the fourth Canadian generation. 

The twins , Claire and Reid  and little brother Lane are half American and live near Tacoma. Washington State. 

They come home to Canada in summer to stay in Kitchener,Ontario, the family cottage in Georgian Bay, swim in  great -grannie's pool in Aurora and camp with cousins  and family members at Sandbanks Provincial Park 

The twins are four years old. They were conceived in Korea  where  mother was  a teacher. Born in Canada  and spent their first five months of life here . 

We  watch them growing  up on facebook and converse with them on Skype.

We live in wondrous times

Friday, 10 January 2014

Neither fish, nor fowl. nor good red herring

It's  Friday night and twenty-five past nine.

I've   eaten , washed the dishes , had tea and shortbread and opened the agenda package Stephanie brought in  the house  when she came home from work.

A couple of nights  ago  she came in laughing with a thousand  piece jigsaw  puzzle in her hand.

"Grannie did you tell people  about the puzzle we did during the power outage"

Packaged and mailed, without a note or  card, To Stephanie C/O Evelyn Buck,  it was thoughtful and kind and  very well received.

Thank you. 

The agenda package is not so well- received. 

The operating budget is part of the package.  We will be working on it from 9.30 a.m. 

The Mayor has called a special  closed meeting for  nine o-clock to authorize staff direction
on a property matter.

There's another closed meeting to deal with another property matter at 6.00 p.m. next Tuesday.

Item 1  on Tuesday's  general committee meeting  there's a 107 page report related to a decision to be made  at the closed meeting to be  held at 6.00p.m. 

I haven't read the 107 page Report. But I  can share the recommendation  from the C.A.O.
that starts the report. 

That Report  CAO 14-001 be received and

That Report CAO 14-001 be forwarded to the February 4, 2014   General Committee meeting for consideration. together with the following  recommendations:

That Council receive  the attached "Hillary-McIntyre Park Cost Benefits  Study" completed by  Sierra Planning and  Management and Carl Bray and Associates: and

That, Staff be authorized to negotiate the terms of agreements of purchase and sale for  Horton 
Place ( 5342 Yonge Street). Readman House (16356 Yonge Street) and Hillary House 
(15372 Yonge Street) properties for Council approval; and

That, staff report back to Council pertaining to: a) the details of the process of developing a master plan for the properties that will guide the long term development and opeations of the three properties, and b) the outcome  of the negotiations o purchase the three properties and to obtain authority to execute any such agreements.

The report that follows this recommendation,as noted above. is 107 page long. 

It is the first item of a meeting that starts at 7.00p.m.

The closed meeting with the confidential attachment to  Report No. CAO 14-001   for Council 's attention , is scheduled for 6.00p.m.  An  hour earlier.

The  closed session agenda notes time of the meeting;  

After New Business Section of  the General Committee agenda . 

That would normally be after Council had actually received the report and discussed it. 

Now.... if the juxtaposition of times of meetings and decisions has you confused ...you are not alone. 

I am too. It feels like a hustle.  

But then,,, I am but a part-time Councillor with little status in the scheme of things. 

Nothing much is expected of  a Councillor and  they are paid accordingly. 

Save for cost of living, Council remuneration has not seen an adjustment since 2003.

The economy was said to be unable to support it. 

On the other hand, the Mayor's salary increased by Bylaw in December , by $9 thousand
and full benefits ..... about  forty per cent increase. 

The Mayor  has been provided  all  employee benefits.

Menial Councillors can enjoy the same benefits but only if  they pay  what it costs. 

I wasn't at the meeting  when the Bylaw was passed. I had a bad bout of bronchitis that deprived me of speech......a temporary affliction. 

The Bylaw  was  likely not called for discussion. 

It would pass unnoticed.

Why  am I writing about it now? 

It's 11pm.   It's been a full day. As it will  be tomorrow. 

My mind is  choc-a-bloc with millions  flowing unimpeded  from the town's treasury, based on expertise of  almost anyone except the town's elected representatives 

Save for one exception. The Mayor. 

A Tortuous Process Unravelled

Anonymous has left a new comment on your post "Budget Quibbles":

Evelyn. I enjoy a food fight as much as the next person. In this instance it is going to be frightfully one sided. The electioneering has begun & councillors seem determined to purchase town votes with town money. I just don't think you can stop them. It is now all about what they want instead of about what Aurora really needs.

****************


It may look like that but it's not as cut and dried as one might think. 

Council is between a couple of big boulders and a slippery slope. 

In 2013, all systems were a-go for an addition and renovations to the town hall. 

I didn't see the need. We are approaching build-out. I think we should be  looking at the possibility of less staff  needing  less space rather than more. 

But Council did exercise their authority. They gave  the green light to proceed every step of the way.

Members  consult  extensively and privately with staff. They fail to  realize the influence they subject themselves to  .... how  much it tilts  their judgement .

Perhaps not unreasonably ,they depend  on staff  advice and  presume responsibility is shared 

It's not. 

Council alone is accountable. 

It's hard to criticize when  Councillors put everything they  feel they ought into making sound decisions. 

Nothing is that simple. 

Months of staff time, consultant studies , architect services ,estimates .

 $300,000 later, Council nixed the town  hall  renovation project.

I believe  that decision was unanimous. 

 It passed without much notice. 

Weeks later, the exercise  is being repeated with a second project three times as costly. 

Last Tuesday, Councillor Gallo, affirming his support for the project from the start, read from reports to indicate why he was re-thinking his position. 

Councillor Pirri appeared  to be expressing reluctance 

Councillor Abel  expressed complete confidence in expert advice  received. and suggested  anyone without his courage  doesn't belong  at the table. 

Councillor Thompson spoke of  need for forward planning and vision 

Next Tuesday, we will discover  the final vote.

Council is faced with a serious dilemma. 

A site has been purchased.  Staff now report "upward cost pressures" created by problems  the site presents .

Original estimates  of $12 million were for a buildable site.

It's hard to keep track of  the figures. 

The  second tab was $14 million.

Following calculations  for building a shelf  into the ravine sufficient  to support the project, estimates  for the complete project became 20  million. 

A  paring  exercise reduced  that to $19 million. 

Council is  currently contemplating that figure.

I am no more able to depend on it than I was the first.

I   now have the right to shout out with glee

 J'accuse !!!!!!!!

Did I not say....but oh no...you  did not listen....such foolishness.....you had to do it your way... make  like big shots you are not..... spending millions of their own money, every day of their lives..... now look at the mess you've got us into Stanley!!!!

But the situation is not  a joke.

The problem  is ours. 

We purchased that site.  

Negotiated to sell existing site. 

Banked on sale of other lands that didn't happen. 

No funding  plan  is in place .

Millions have  already been spent in the process.  The complete tally, we know not.

How can a Council change direction without acknowledging  serious and costly mis-calculation. 

Which way do they turn?

According to the  tone of  discussion  on Tuesday , the vote may be split with Mayor Dawe breaking the tie in favor of proceeding. 

My own advice:

First  ....be upfront  and acknowledge the problem.  It  was well-intentioneed but it can't be swept under the rug. 

Second,  the  whole Council  is  needed to engage in  the  resolution. 

It's no time for a pissing contest between  factions.

A split decision will do nothing to assure the taxpayers.

Tension isn't bad

Anonymous has left a new comment on your post "Collegiality is not like other relationships.":

11:47.... Yes, this tension always has been there. In the 20 years I have lived here, there has NEVER been a council that got along. I used to have a weekly social engagement with a councillor from a number of terms ago (late 90's) and he said that "everyone on council are nice people - alone and outside the building. Get them in that room and they become monsters."

**********************


The last three years  have been nothing like the previous sixteen when there was a particular strain of 
mean spirit within Coumcil.

Man's inhumanity to man was  never so prevalent.

Politics atracts a varietty of personalities.

None are shy and retiring.

The late Dick  politician Illingworth used to say... " you don't have to be crazy but it helps"

It also  helps  to have a sense of the ridiculous. 

Politicians are often ridiculous. Being  people , it's hard to see how that can be avoided.

To be without humour  is to be without  judgement.

It is to be without discernment.

It is to be mean,meaner and meanest.

A recent comment reminded me of something this Council reversed at the beginning of the term. 

An earlier Council had honoured the sitting Mayor John West by allowing  a  major right of way to bear his name.

Several years later, a Councillor, Nigel Keane, who had run  and lost for Mayor moved to have the street renamed. The motion lost but it had enough support to get on the table.

During a later term, Kean tried again. Only this time  he moved to give the town hall parking lot a street name , in order  to have West's name  removed from town hall stationery.

 The second time. he accomplished his objective with the same seconder .

Every street in my neghborhood  is named after a Councillor of the day when the homes were built . I doubt many  current residents are aware of the fact.

New streets must be named.

One name  is as good as another.

But it takes  a particularly hostile individual to move to remove an honour bestowed  years before.

John West  was a colleague at the table when  Coumcillor  Kean did  the dirty.

Kean was  three times a candidate for Mayor without success.

West  won the  honour three times.

Naked hatred is  never pleasing to witness. It usually indicates something meaner and
nastier below.

In politics ,it  has no curb appeal.

Heaven help us all when it gains supremacy and assumes authority.

It has not reared its  ugly head  during  the current term.

Thursday, 9 January 2014

Budget Quibbles

Budget all day Saturday. I can't feel positive about it. I will continue to oppose  funding for the Culture Centre.

I will  argue  for museum  funding. But the grant to the  Historical Society should be transferred  to the museum  and the grant to the Culture Centre should be significantly reduced.

 I do not agree taxpayers should be "buying" culture .

 Culture  has had status in the town since Noah built the Ark.Museum service is culture  As are Library Services ......Pottery Club ...Art Society....Writers'  Club .....Arboretum.;;;as infinitum.

All add to  our quality  of life.

I just don't believe, other than  finding facilities, it should add to the tax burden.

So...it's a budget item.

The Capital  Construction Budget was approved last week. My vote was not in favor.

$3 million  are budgeted to change all street lighting to LED in one fell swoop.

LED lighting is expensive because it' s new.

It's not proven. Hasn't been around long enough.

Disposal of existing ,still functional lighting , adds to waste disposal and capacity problems.

We are all about reducing and re-cycling.

Lighting is not organic. Is there a program for re-cycling light fixtures?

In our own households, would we change light bulbs while they still had life?

Would we change every bulb in the house before we've  even tested something new.

Do we swallow holus-bolus every commercial promotion aimed at us?

St John's Sideroad and Leslie Street are changing  to urban standards. Illumination is to be added. Makes  sense to use LED lighting .

Development charges will  properly  finance the project.

Adding $3 million  to  2014 capital construction budget  for the purpose is  not responsible financial management.

Re-lining water  pipes with plastic theoretically reduces water loss. The town has spent an average of $1million a year for ten  years without  a monitor for effectiveness.

If there is merit,  the Region should be footing the bill.  Responsibility for water supply and waste management is Regional. They collect development charges for the  purpose.

Water rates are a tax. Increases should be reflected in the tax bill. They should not be separated out to create illusion and confusion.

The capital construction budget  has an item to install a bulk water meter at St.Andrew's Village
Retail Centre. Individual properties have been metered. The Centre itself has not. A meter at  town
cost  of $80,000. is to be  installed at the property line.

It means  the centre will pay for all water  consumed. Until now, the  real cost has been
subsidized within the  ate calculation.

It is time for calculation of water rates downwards.

These arguments  are not new.

 I am nothing ,if not persistent.

They continue to be valid .

A person comments  this morning the lease of our hydro building is a deal that cannot be broken.

Not so.

A sale  is a deal that cannot be undone.

A lease is not the same thing.

Termination of that lease  is worth  more than any federal grant that may or may not be available to build a new facility  to meet the town's needs.

We own the building. Our responsibility is the town's interest. The armories sits vacant taking up space in the corner our park. The federal government continues to seek ways to reduce expenses.
That is their mandate. one way it  to reduce funds for the militia. It should not be done  at the expense of Aurora taxpayers.

If public works needs are as urgent as stated  ,the hydro building  is urgently needed for  the parks department.

No ifs ands or buts.

Rent  revenue for the building is a drop in the bucket compared to spending  required to create a level site  for a joint facility on the side of a ravine in the flood plain of the valley of the Holland River .

Pshaw!!!!!!!!!!

Wednesday, 8 January 2014

Collegiality is not like other relationships.

Something else I forgot to mention;  a massive retaining wall is having to be built  to create a level site for  building. Storage sheds are being built against it  for equipment like tractors and stuff.

Councillor  Thompson  sees it  as an advantage. When I inquired what  works or parks equipment needed  to be stored indoors? . He replied he didn't suggest it. . He said  a shed would  make it more accessible.

Somebody mentioned this morning Councillor Ballard had referred to my blog in a tweat.

I don't  tweat.   So I have no idea what Councillor Ballard might be saying .

But the comment provides opportunity to  explain  what might be  difficult to understand otherwise

Councillor Ballard  and I are poles apart on many issues.

Others ....not so much.

We are not  socially acquainted.

 It's not a requirement.

I am aware  he has been critical

It matters not.

For the purpose of  Council, we are colleagues,

 Being of like mind on town issues is not a requirement.

I have never had an uncivil  exchange with Councillor Ballard, nor Councillor Gallo nor Councillor  Gaertner .

I  regard  bad manners to be unacceptable in any circumstance.

On the

other hand, engaged  in a  struggle for dominance of ideas on a town issue, I would  draw blood. metaphorically, if I had to.

 I don't carry a notebook  filled with grudges  It would be altogether too much clutter.

On the other hand ...I don't forget much either.


Anonymous has left a new comment on your post "A Step in the right direction":


What exactly was the problem with the site on which the AFLC was built?

Reference is made to "the same geological area."

Is there a sub-soil condition? Was this a swamp many years ago?

It would be nice to know this.

******************


Stick a pin in a map of Aurora  and  it will likely hit a  natural spring or  quick sand.  

1963 was the first  time I ran for Council. It was also Aurora' s Centennial. The original library building was the town's Centennial project. The late  Councillor Jean Moffat was chair of the
Library Building Committee.

On the night of the Inaugural Council Moffat told  the audience how she had fought for a basement in the building but couldn't get any support.

The reason? Soil conditions.

Aurora Community Centre  opened in 1967.

It had to have a  floating concrete slab to provide  support for one corner of the building.

The swimming pool in the Aurora Family Leisure Complex  literally  fell through the bottom and had to be re-built , at least once.

The  addition to the AFLC required extra  funding because  of soil conditions.

The site for the Joint Facility edges into the flood  plain  calling  for cut  and fill. It will be monitored by the Conservation  Authority which will dictate requirements as they find them .

The area abuts the Arboretum . From experience we know the soil to be sandy. 

A second access and egress  to te site is required  because of the main entrance being on a curve and a steep incline  slopes down to the yard.

To people who  have lived in Aurora  for any time, none of this is new. The ravine runs from north to south of the town and beyond.  The site is in the ravine. Whether it was once a swamp, I do not know. But unstable soil conditions is just a reality we live with. 

There are  those who observed extraordinary pumping activity  during construction of  the current library .

I wasn't a member of Council  at the time of construction  so I don't know the story and  I 
never found anyone willing to admit to problems. 

All of this experience and knowledge of the geological nature of the town,  was always good reason to use the former hydro site for our own purpose. What we had on Scanlon Court   was equally safe. 

There was certainty . 

No guess work required.

Included in te current $18million  price tag is the cockamamie  fqcility for treating melting snow. 

We  spent $300,000 for "swing space"  and prearing for additions to the Town hall  hich ae mot now happening. Having been nixed by Council. 

We could have invested that money in a snow melter and been a lot further ahead. 

At the end of this month  we wl ave an extra yard waste collection. Allthe usual rules apply. Branches must be cut to a certain size and bundled, 

We re talking about fallen tree limbs and branchesalready substantially snow covered iand frozen to the ground. 




A Step in the right direction

John Abel has left a new comment on your post "Ah But...Ya gotta love politics":

We can all agree on one thing Councillor Buck;

A new Joint Operation Centre wouldn't even be up for consideration had the Town maintained the old Hydro Building.

That property and building is a perfect compliment to the Scalon yard.

On an aside. I thought the coffee was terrible last night. I couldn't drink mine.

***************


Thank you for that CouncillorAbel.

The Parks department  were occupying the Hydro building. They were building parks furniturei in the   workshop in the winter.

Office space  was used  for town archive storage.

Heritage salvage was  handily stored in the yard.

It's a five acre site .

Parks were evicted from the facility to make room for  "the kiddies to play" as expressed by the former Mayor.

Hundreds of thousands of dollas were spent on the building Federal government use.

A lease was signed for ten years , at a rent unrelated to the value  and loss of the facility for  town purposes.

The  lease is not a public document because of national security.

We  believe there is  no termination clause. What kind of a lease is that?

This Council has not even asked the question.

We purchased a new site for the  joint facility because the price was "right"

The sites problems are now cited as the reason for the "upward cost pressures"

The Aurora Family Leisure Complex  is in the same  geological area.  Problems experienced with that building were surely sufficient to warn of difficulties of  making that site useable for the purpose.

Access and egress is onto the horrendously busy Industrial Parkway is seriously compromised

.Works and Parks are  entirely truck  and equipment operations.

Imagine sand and road materials in  the huge  dump trucks  required for delivery, negotiating access and egress on  and from a  steep incline  onto an artery designed  to serve  and acting as bypass for Yonge Street traffic.

Councillor, I do not have to  be an engineer to understand the function of a works and parks yard
and to know that site was never suitable  for the purpose.

Familiarity  based on experience of the function of a works and parks  yard  is all that;s required to exercise sensible judgement. didn't get it overnight. It took fifty years to hone what I know into common sense decisions.

I  simply have no confidence in the constantly changing kaleidoscope of figures provided at last night's meeting. Even less when it became obvious  thr Mayor and key Councillors had already made a decision and were prepared to use the issue  to degrade the authority of Council.

As far as I'm concerned this was one of the horrendously costly mistakes this Council was elected to reverse.

Who is it with the courage on behalf of the taxpayers we represent. to  tell  the Department of National Defense   and  Queen's York Rangers, the town's need is greater than yours ...you need to surrender the field?

I don't see anyone on this Council of Goodwill Ambassadors  so eager to be all things  to all people no matter  the cost.

Since  I am not the Chief of Toronto Police Department and I am more than one-time elected  I  believe I may claim the right to say on behalf of myself and the people I represent. I am  profoundly disappointed  without being told I have no right to sit at the  Council table.

It was so cold last night, I  enjoyed the hot coffee and thank you for bringing it to me.

I had to share


Your morning chuckle



Just got off the phone with a cousin who lives in Scotland.

She said that since early this morning the snow has been nearly waist high and is still falling. The temperature is dropping far below zero and the north wind is increasing to near gale force. Her husband has done nothing but look through the kitchen window and just stare. She says that if it gets much worse, she may have to let the drunken bastard in.
    
________________________________________________________

Ah But...Ya gotta love politics

 I'm going to have to raise a Question of Privilege at the next Council meeting.

It's  a means of resolving a problem before it  sets  into  festering resentment.

This one  seems to have already degraded.

I don't know why he swallowed a fly.

Councillor Abel has acquired a habit of casting aspersions against anyone who fails to recognize  great wisdom when he speaks.

If any one of four Councillors takes a position different to his own. he puts it down to taking a position  different to his own......like it's  a thoroughly scurrilous, underhanded , mean spirited attack against all that is good  and pure and courageous.......namely himself.

It's the attitude that spawned the Code of Cnduct in the last Council. I have come to believe it's a generational thing.

He'll say, I know why  the Councillor is  opposed.   It's because he/she has been opposed from the beginning. I'm para-phrasing.

Last night the lofty  sentiment went a step further.

Anyone  who is afraid to make the kind of decisions he is brave enough to make, didn't deserve to have a place at the Council table , was the gist of it.

He's prepared to accept the advice of the professionals because they know,you know.

If  a reports  indicates a $12...$14...$20,,,$18 million project can be built without impact on the tax rate and the taxpayers won't even know it happened, that's good enough for Councillor Abel and anyone who  doesn't agree, doesn't deserve a seat at the table.

Shades of the past.

It's such a simple unambiguous perspective of biblical proportions, on a clear night, one can almost detect  a scintilla of  something. .. yearning perhaps...for the good old days.

The presiding member  is responsible to call a Councillor to order when he falls into error by impugning or assigning motive to another.

The Mayor  seldom  does . It  seems to depend on who's motives are  being impugned  and whether he agrees with the impugnment.

Councillor Gaertner is a favorite target, myself  quickly becoming an alternate.

Pinning my hide to the wall appears once again to be a universally admirable objective.

The object of the rule of order  is to stop  matters from descending into a name-calling. rabble-rousing, undignified, gutter level , mud-wrestling encounter.

Next step fisticuffs .like battling kangaroos.

Fit for neither man nor beast

At 20 degrees , it was a night for neither man nor beast.

I thought seriously about whether I should  go . The issue was about the joint public works and parks facility. I needed to be there. Cost estimates had increased by millions.

Turned out , I didn't need to be there after all. The decision to  proceed with the project had already been made by the Mayor, Councillors Thompson, Humfreys  and  Abel . I'm not certain about Councillor Pirri's  position.

Way back,  before  the site was selected ,  cost estimates were  $12 million.

A problematic site was  purchased .   Estimates rose  to $14 million .

Various costs were firmed up. Estimates rose to $20 million.

Staff worked to  reduce  estimates.  The forecast now stands  at $18 million.

Not to worry, in response to judiciously placed question by Councillor Thompson , staff  informed Council , Newmarket spent $20 million on their facility.

From which we may  logically deduce.......ours  is a bargain at  $18 million.

Newmarket has a  current population of  75,000 going to 100,000  when built out.

Another question  from Councillor Thompson elicited  information the facility could be built without impact  on the tax rate.

Ergo...no political  impact.

Who wouldn't love a Council  that  could build an $18million facility without  incrasing the tax rate by as much as a nickel.

Councillor Abel is persuaded anyone who can't make decisions like that, doesn't belong at the  Council table.He repeated the sentiment.

I realized then there  hadn't really been much point in coming out into the   hazard of the extreme cold.

The Mayor and Councillors  of similar mind had all the information they needed to make a decision without bothering with a pesky Council discussion.

So much  is made about obtaining public input.

Yet  there is neither time, patience nor inclination to even  pretend to hear from people elected  like themselves for the purpose of sharing perspective.

I made the observation.

It was not denied.

Indeed .....the Mayor  intimated .Councillors who were not comfortable going forward  with the project at the price, had  done the same thing .  Myself  included, they too had agreed to a pre-determined position. 

It was deja vu. 

The night Councillors Abel and Pirri  moved to  give notice to terminate the agreement with the Culture Centre Board , flashed before my eyes. 

The debate had been full and complete .

The Mayor spoke to the merits of the resolution with facts  and conviction. As did Councillors Thompson and Humfreys. 

The Mayor had not spoken as much to any other issue before, nor has he since. 

The debate ended . The only thing  left was to call the vote  

There was a pause that  stretched  out , to the confusion of all  but three present.

Something was  clearly anticipated. 

Sure enough , an amendment moved by Councillor Humfreys,seconded by Councillor Thompson  effectively scuttled the original  motion.

The term had barely begun. 

We are in the final stretch. 

It seems it wil end as it began. 








Tuesday, 7 January 2014

What does any of it mean ?

Anonymous has left a new comment on your post "Anonymous has left a new comment on your post "GUE...":

9:34...

How does a bi-sexual wife or multi-racial childred determine whether a person will be a good mayor?

*****************


How does  one determine whether any candidate will be a good  Mayor?

The only clue I offer is a candidate's record  in the job.

The relevance of extraneous factors in an election campaign is a different question. 

New York's Mayor has term limit

I can't begin to imagine what it takes, apart from a fortune in a campaign chest, to  organize a 
New York Mayoralty contest. 

It certainly bespeaks private resources. I  read former Mayor  Michael Bloomberg spent millions of his personal resources on city programs. It seems he left the city better than he found it. 

Names  of challengers to  Rob Ford of Toronto are coming forward

The question that comes to mind is the strength of the campaign organization and  sufficiency of campaign resources.

Name recognition on the ballot is also a key factor.

Rob Ford's organization, campaign resources  and name recognition are all  likely as strong if not stronger  than they were the first time around.

Former  TTC chairman  and Councillor Giambrone was a challenger for a bit in the last election. Endorsed by David Miller ,who lamented his withdrawal from the race after sleaze  reported in te media reflected on his  personal standards and integrity.

He never  made it to the starting line.

George Smitherman  made an issue of lifestyle and family status as  campaign promotion. A lifetime of provincial politics and party support behind  him didn't help. Rob Ford  beat him handily at the polls.

Rob Ford talked  about city spending run amuk and the need to stop it.
He talked about tax rates and the burden on property owners.

Michael Ignatieff wrote a book after his failed attempt to become Prime Minister of Canada. He acknowledged he didn't understand until the night before the election that the campaign was not
about him. It was about the people who came out to see him and  hear him  in myriad small village halls and Legions , on cold , wet and windy nights all  across the country , to  get a sense
of  what he was about.

Could they trust him to  care about their problems up there  in the Parliament buildings in Ottawa.

Turned out, they decided  they  didn't.

It's all about new discovery

When I  bought  a computer I had no idea how to use it. Even less did I know the impact it would have on my life.

I had a sense of it.

But my first experience was a fat  negative.

I acquired an e-mail address.

As a  Council candidate, I made it known. It was like the polar bear plunge. I had no how to use te computer but  there ws no other way to find out. 
I received a phone call from a candidate who'd heard I was the only candidate who had not responded to a  questionnaire from the Aurora Banner. The deadline had passed. I called the editor to ask for an extension.

Deborah Kelly's  response was hostile. 
"It's not  our job to chase after candidates " she said.
I'd never spoken to the woman. Certainly there had been no exchange to account for the lack of civility.

The questionnaire was the only acknowledgement of the election 
The Banne was the only  newspaper in town at the time. 
Since tere was no reason I could identify, I decided it didn't exist. It was a figment of   political paranoia peculiar to politicians.

I was wrong  about that.

I fooled arou with the computer some  more for no particular purpose. 
I was elected in another election and met up with similar hostility. 
I still  couldn't pin-point a reason. But I could no longer dismiss the reality. I thought  about blogging.
You know what they say about the best defense. 
Still ...I knew nothing about blogging. 
I asked  and discovered I'd spent money acquiring a domain. It was as expensive  as it was a mis-step.

I  read about successful bloggers. One story made a particular impression. 
The publisher had been  diagnosed with a terminal illness. He blogged daily about dying.Thousands of people logged in and joined him in his journey.

I wasn't one.  I  figure that's a journey none of us need to take more than once.

I went to the senior's centre and  learned someting of the practical application of blogging .

About the same time, a young  knowledgeable  neigbor became interested in what I was struggling to achieve and became both teacher and associate.It was a period when she needed a diversion.

Helping  me acquire rudimentary  computer skills provided what  she needed at the time  I needed help.

I had not become proficient by the time her life turned  around as I knew it would but I had learned enough to limp along .

The blog evolved to belong to more than myself alone.

At one and the same time, the immediate nature of communication  is both its strength and  frailty.

It is what it is.

Now I am dealing with  something new.

The experience pre-occupies my mind but I can't  tell the story.   For now.

If I  blogged six times as often , it would not be enough to tell  story I need to tell.

It must wait.

While  it waits... it's hard to focus on anything else.

That's a new  discipline to be mastered.

We  celebrated the life of  former Mayor John West today.

The closing words were spoken  by others. 

It's what we do. 

John was of a generation that had  no access  to planning. 

Life was earned  as it came. It had to be embraced because there was no other way.

 I am as  certain  as I can be, John's  life was better than his wildest dreams anticipated.

He would have no regrets. 

That's as  good  as it gets.  









Saturday, 4 January 2014

Anonymous has left a new comment on your post "GUEST POST":


In today's Globe and Mail, in the Focus Section, the entire article from yesterdays paper is reprinted, together with a photo of Justice Nadon that occupies almost half of the full page coverage.

In the original comment there was a concluding sentence that "This appointment smacks too much of politics and stacking the court to further Mr. Harper's fight for the rights of the right." This sentence was omitted from the Guest Post.

If one reads the Globe and Mail article there are numerous references to the politics behind the appointment. In a year-end interview with the media Mr. Harper repeated his long touted goal to transform criminal law so that it is no longer "centred on the welfare of the criminal." This tough on crime approach is a central and popular part of his agenda. Changes to the Criminal Code have put more people in federal prisons than ever before and this is behind his vision for the bench. Many judges have rebelled against the newly instituted mandatory minimum sentences that come from the Harper pro-right wing of his party.

Osgoode Hall law professor Jamie Cameron, says she has a rule not to comment publicly on the attributes of appointees - but she is breaking her rule this time. "What the appointment shows is the prime minister lacks respect for the Supreme Court as an institution. I feel very strongly that the orderly progression and evolution of the law requires a strong court - a court that's capable and willing to demonstrate leadership. I think that this appointment unquestionably weakens the court."

Our laws are written by the legislators, but they can and must be subject to interpretation by the judiciary, a judiciary that is knowledgeable and impartial.

Publish
Delete
Mark as spam

Moderate comments for this blog.

Posted by Anonymous to Our Town and Its Business at 4 January 2014 18:00

GUEST POST

THE HIGH COST OF JUSTICE


Let me quote from an article in yesterday's Globe and Mail:

"At 62, Justice Marc Nadon of Ottawa has reached the magic number.

His age plus his 18 years in the Federal Court's trial and appeal divisions added up to 80 - allowing him the option to work about half his usual hours and still receive his full pay of $288,100. An option he took. To mark the transition, he took four weeks off for a southern holiday, then returned to a lightened workload."

His appointment by the Prime Minister to the Supreme Court, an appointment that has been challenged by the Province of Quebec and a Toronto lawyer, is presently up in the air. Ironically it will be up to the Supreme Court to rule on his acceptability.

Some time ago he moved into an office in the Supreme Court building, notwithstanding the challenges to his appointment. He was directed to remove himself forthwith. Some cojones.

If he is ultimately confirmed by his future fellow justices he can look forward to an annual salary, as of April 1, 2013, of $351,700.

It would be interesting to know what his annual pension would be if he serves until retirement age of 75.

Thursday, 2 January 2014

Apropos A Comment

Being out of touch during the crisis , I cannot speak  personally for how things were handled by the town.

But the Mayor was on top of  things. Provided regular bulletins gand extended heartfelt thanks to all who participated in providing assistace to those  in need.

My street still has a thick layer of ice .But I did see a bylaw officer's car at  Glass Drive corner .

Aurora's town staff  have always performed well  in emergency. It  takes a  crisis to bring out the best  in  town staff . They know how much  isdependent   and rally to the cause every time.

But this one was different. This year, under the new customer service program, theTown announced  regular service would be maintained between Christmas  and New Year.

It's not usually.

When I came back in 2003 , I questioned that.

The logic was, there is no demand for service  during that period.  Staff took vacation time.

It seems  this year , numbers of senior staff still took vacation time.

I understand there wasn't a supervisor or a manager  who wasn't on vacation from public works  during the  crisis.

We will no doubt be  having  a review.


Bizarre Aftermath to an Ice Storm ...Pixie Dust

A couple of silly things happened at my house during the week that was. Too silly to talk about.

A couple  of other things  happened  that also don't make sense. I have a feeling they will not go away unless I  do talk about them.

When cable came back ,I watched Toronto residents who had moved out  of their homes to stay with family with amenities, return to their homes every day to check the water pipes. To see if they had frozen and burst.

I thought, why did they not just turn off the water supply? Don't they know they can do that?

Then there were the people whose food spoiled; if  pipes  would freeze in unheated houses, why would food spoil in unheated houses?  Why would a deep freeze not keep food from spoiling?

It's why we have refrigerators.

And why did we see the Provincial Premier, fit from her  campaign commercial uphill run, knock on doors  to deliver  food baskets? Only to Toronto residents?

What if people behind the door had the normal overflow of Christmas cheer ? What would they think to find the Provincial Premier standing on the  doorstep with a basket of whatever provender some stranger thought to toss together?

Barney Miller used to be a favorite comedy show of mine. The perps kept it fresh. On one show. Wojohowitz brought  a perp in under arrest for   begging  at a commuter train station
He was a trader  at NewYork Stock Market. Live in Connecticut,in a big house ,with a maid and a driver.

Claimed he made more money as  a beggar.

I thought of him when Provincial Premier Kathleen Wynne announced to all and sundry, vouchers worth a hundred dollars would be handed out willy-nilly  at Ontario Work Centers in Toronto on January 1st;

Had it been April 1st, it might have made more sense.

Come on down the Premier announced, we got  money to give away. No questions asked.

If Rob Ford had done that, Toronto media, or  the Police Chief  perhaps , would have  claimed to have a video, bought from extortionists , showing the Mayor smoking something , maybe crack cocaine but nothing  he could  be charged with, from  a glass bowl.

It would  have to be a bowl. It couldn't be just a pipe. To justify the largesse.

Like the  media I  digress.

It wasn't Rob Ford.

It 's  the Honorable and Generous and Caring  Kathleen  Wynne  giving away money to all comers in Toronto.

The same  Honorable who  thinks  an apology from a politician is  sufficient  to compensate for  a one point one billion dollar boondoggle  undertaken for purely political  purpose.

Wednesday, 1 January 2014

In 2014...A Guid New Year tae Yin and A'

Some have meat but cannot eat
Some would eat if they had it
But we have meat and we can eat
and so The Lord be thankit

And we have light and  heat and fuel for cooking ,
And television. telephone and internet
And thanks to  an ice  storm,we know what it's like to be without
And so The Lord be  doubly thankit.

There was certainly misery enough in the city to keep me from complaining

One of the last things I watched before cable blacked out ,was the  Mansbridge interview  on Tweeting with Margaret Atwood. He outed her  that she still has an electric typewriter,a manual typewriter and of all things,   a pen . is kept handy.

I couldn't help thinking about teachers who feel cursive writing is an obsolete skill that no longer needs to be taught.

A woman last night told how she had to sleep on the floor during the blackout. The family were forced to sleep n sleeping bags but she had to stay on the floor in hers to keep the fire going all night.

I shook my head  twice at  that.

I'd been thinking how one might prepare for an ice storm.  I've  always missed  a fire .ln the house. I wouldn't exchange it for central heating. But  a fire  in the grate is a spiritually comforting thing.

Even if  it was ever warm enough in  a Scottish summer not to have a fire in the hearth , the house
was strangelyempty without one.

But we never burned  the fire all night long.
We made sure the bed was warm and cosy.
Getting  up in the cold was hard to do .
But, oh no, we never needed a fire when warm in our beds.
There was and still is something  special about that too.

During the power outage, I put my head out the door to smell wood burning smoke from someone else's house.

So....many of us ended 2013, without some of the comforts we take for granted.

Because  of it,  we start 2014 with a new appreciation for all the good things  we normally enjoy without even thinking .

I did get  my Christmas cards  off to Scotland. I didn't get the Canadian ones away before the  storm.

I forgot to mention, my car was iced in to the driveway as well .


I received mail with  many bright and beautful cards of good wishes  and they  brightened my space.

Now on this first day, my wish to one and all is , A Guid New Year In 2014.

There's lots to talk about in the weeks to come.