Anonymous has left a new comment on your post "So Soon Forgotten...or Never Understood ?":
I thought you were not going to post disparaging comments about your fellow councillors? Does Thompson not count?
Posted by Anonymous to Our Town and Its Business at 17 July 2014 14:26
************
Councillor Thompson certainly counts. It seems though we may have different ideas about what is disparaging to a Councillor.
My reference was to failure to observed rules of order. I hardly call that disparaging. Any Councilor can find themselves in that situation . We are not robots. That's. why we have rules of order and a Presiding Member whose role it is to maintain the rules.
If the Presiding Member has no experience things are quite likely to go off the rails fast.
The only way to learn is by practice . It's not easy when the Chair himself has little sense of
pitfalls.
When a Councillor is criticized,chances are a reaction will trigger. Before you know it mayhem erupts.
We've seen eruptions in foreign parliaments with members
throwing things at each other and lunging over desks to get at each other's throats.
We've not seen the like in Canada But one memorable occasion the Honorable Sheila Copps went over the desks to get at The Honorable John Crosby for a denigrating remark against her.
I myself have been accused ofunruly behavior . it was an attempt at humor that fell flat.
I'm not sure what's worse unruly conduct or failed humor..
It led to my finest performance when I apologized and my friend Ron Wallace of forty-five years graciously accepted . The Council chamber was full that night and we received. a hearty round of applause which made the whole episode worthwhile.
Being a member of a Council that works well together is a very satisfying experience. It doesn't mean everyone has to think the same.
It does mean everyone has to be able to express true thoughts and convictions without being afraid of offending someone else's sensitivities.
If it happens inadvertently there's a remedy.
It really is a skill worth learning. The Chair and Councillors with experience. Are usual models.
As has been noted, this Council has been short on both.The rules are not well understood.
I find myself against the glass age barrier. They see my lips moving but don't hear what I'm saying.
The blog is my second chance to make a difference.?.....poking with a pointy stick.
When Councillors read what the community reads and the community reaction I hope for better understanding.
We have a common purpose is serve the interest of the people who sent us.
Working at odds doesn't cut it.
For a majority to agree on a position before coming to the table is not my idea of a cohesive unit.
Outside of council there's a common belief that's how politics work.
It is not . Things do not get accomplished .
There's nothing in government like the satisfaction of working together and moving the municipality forward.
When something is right ....it's easy to recognize.. Takinggratuitous
I kept hoping. .....
My goodness ! I cannot believe you were taken over the coals for putting up a comment inferring that Cllr Thompson tends to put listeners to sleep. He also says " you know " frequently.
ReplyDeleteThere have been plenty of comments on most of the other councillors without causing offence. Why is someone so concerned about this one ?
ReplyDeleteIt's good that we are getting closer to the end than the beginning.
I think we learn from the comments & observations of others.
ReplyDeleteVery early in this term, someone referred to councillor Humfryes as " The Thank-You Lady ". I had never heard that term before. It took a little while to figure out.
It was very accurate.
A very busy week or so. I was wondering what could be discussed over the summer when nothing much happens. With the Ukraine mess, Mr Duffy and the play-enacting to replace cllr Ballard, there appears to be plenty of material for you. Have at it.
ReplyDelete"I think we learn from the comments & observations of others."
ReplyDeleteOnly if we're allowed to, 17:34.
"disparaging" really? If that was "disparaging" I would be jailed for some of my choice words that I throw out when hearing some of these theatrical performances I hear in council.
ReplyDeleteNew candidates being registered in the run for councillor. One very good one & a couple of ringers.
ReplyDeleteWhich is the good one and who are the ringers?
ReplyDelete12:01
ReplyDeleteActually I have 2 possibles now. if one considers the entire list. Remarkable.