"Cowardice asks the question...is it safe? Expediency asks the question...is it politic? Vanity asks the question...is it popular? But conscience asks the question...is it right? And there comes a time when one must take a position that is neither safe, nor politic, nor popular but one must take it because it is right." ~Dr. Martin Luther King

Thursday, 13 May 2010

Thoughtful And Correct....Up To A Point

Anonymous has left a new comment on your post "Homecoming":

Evelyn, I agree with everything you said, this is a foolish decision but I think you have been unduly harsh in your criticism of the resident who fought for it. All home owners are "selfish" about their properties. Although it is undeniable that the town owns a few metres at the bottom of everyone's property, it is only natural that we think of it as our own. We nurture and care for it as we do the rest of our lot and we are responsible for its aesthetic maintenance. The resident did the right thing, he had a concern, went to the Mayor and fought for what he wanted. It is not his fault that council granted his request at the expense of his neighbours and fellow taxpayers. Although I agree that the Town has a responsibility to work with citizens for the betterment of all neighbourhoods, in the end it is up to the elected members to determine how best to utilize community owned property. It is them that must be held accountable for their decisions. No homeowner is objective about their own property or neighbourhood, that is job of their elected government. I think in fairness you owe him an apology. And it is council that owes an apology to his neighbours.

The foregoing was received this morning and the writer is correct.

I have said before that every citizen has a right to defend whatever he sees as his interest.

There are a couple of peculiarities here which provoked the criticism.

This neighbour collected a petition in opposition to a sidewalk when the town allowed residents to state their preference.He sought my support and I gave it freely.

Most of the street has sidewalk already. The new construction is closing a gap

Since the petition was collected, policy changed. People still have the right to express preference. But traffic pattern and pedestrian safety will be the determining factor. It's a good policy and I support it.

New information disclosed Nisbet Drive is heavily used as an alternative for drivers and pedestrians to reach commercial shopping on Yonge Street or conversely the liquor store at the corner of Brookland.

It is not unusual for cars to mount the curb and plow the boulevard in that neighbourhood.

Boulevards serve as snow storage. They also protect pedestrians from potential hazard such as the one above.

Sidewalks, even seven foot wide, cannot be kept clear and be used as snow storage.

Pedestrians, in the main, are the elderly, children and youth, mothers with strollers , the disabled and people walking pets.

These are the people needing the safety of a properly placed sidewalk.

To accommodate the new alignment, a considerable stretch of sidewalk in good condition will be broken out and discarded.

Trees being cut down are town trees in beautiful condition, in front of number 63 .

The new metre of road on the west side will require a new base and catch basins re-aligned.

A hydro transformer and vault will be closer to the travelled portion of the road and there are hydro cables which as far as I am aware have not been examined in the plans.

Neighbours' property are not all that's affected by this bastardised plan.

We are currently contemplating thousands,potentially millions of dollars in current and future budgets to improve public amenities to accommodate mobility for the disabled.

Miles of sidewalk are missing or in need of renewal within the town.

This small section was but a step in the right direction and the town is not taking it.

I acknowledge Council is responsible for the decision.

I acknowledge my criticism is severe. But I draw the line at an apology

When a citizen comes to the public forum to argue for a particular decision in his favour and so influence decision-making, privacy is surrendered and views are subject to the same analysis and criticism as any elected member seated at the table.

The only thing they do not share is responsibility for the decision.

However, in my book, my highly intelligent and influential neighbour in Nisbet Drive is not excused for his lack of social responsibility.

In my experience, knowledge that a self-serving demand can only be accommodated at the expense of one's neighbours is generally what keeps most people from making outrageously,
blatant,self-serving demands.

My neighbour has not witheld his criticism.

Of course,who can know what assurances were received by the supplicant of the righteousness of his request in the privacy of the Mayor's office.

Nah! that's still not an excuse. He is too smart to be taken in by that. More likely he was exploiting it to his advantage. .

Wednesday, 12 May 2010

Homecoming

Last night a glass with ice was on the table by my chair and a message from a Nisbet Drive neighbour was waiting for me when I got home.

"Tell your mother, we all appreciate what she did for us tonight"

It was nice. But it was little enough I was able to accomplish.

I told Council, Nisbet Drive residents felt they should have had an opportunity to comment on the changed construction plans for their road.

Councillor Gaertner dismissed that. Residents had plenty of opportunity to comment,she said.

The Mayor advised residents should come and see her and Public Works Director, Simanovskis if they had a problem.

Mayor Morris is certainly right about that. One resident of Nisbet Drive went to see her and the Public Works Director and the road design was promptly changed to suit his preference.

Along his property frontage, the sidewalk loops and becomes a concrete pad six feet wide, abutting the travelled portion of the road. Not only that. The road itself is to be shifted over by three feet to take the sidewalk even further from his property.

Neighbours opposite will have three feet less depth to their frontage.

To satisfy totally selfish and self-centred demands of a single individual,three beautiful street trees, two of them with probably thirty years of growth, will be cut down to be replaced by the concrete pad.

But apparently that's acceptable. Because he took his problem to the Mayor. The Mayor ensured his every wish was granted. Like a Fairy Godmother.

So chuffed was he with the success of his efforts, he boasted to neighbours about how effective he had been and how well the Mayor had taken care of his needs.

His success had been at his neighbours expense, but never did it occur to him the information might not be universally welcomed.

It's interesting to watch Mormac politics in action.

Little subtlety is involved.

By summer's end , the hybrid sidewalk will be on the ground for all to see.

Visit Nisbet Drive now and see how it is. Council awarded the contract last night with one vote opposed.

The trees will be the first to vanish. Go and see them now in all their glory of spring foliage. Take some photos. Talk to the neighbours. Give them an ear.

Next time a righteous Councillor expresses an opinion about the value of a tree, know that for the crock it is.

I've been to a few gatherings lately. In the company of neighbouring politicians.

Aurora Council meetings are being viewed far and wide.

Tuesday, 11 May 2010

Water Rates Homework

I logged in to the Town web site this morning I needed to check the budget.

I voted against the water rate increase. The press report noted the vote to support was seven to one. And that's where the story ended. More than likely because that's where the available space ended. But the story wasn't complete

So, the pressure is on me, myself alone, to keep following my nose.

One explanation for the increase was a change in book-keeping. Until this year, cost of maintaining water lines has been charged to a capital reserve fund established for the purpose of maintaining water lines.

The treasurer and public works director decided during budget preparation, before the year end, that should be changed.

It meant a transfer $250,000 from a charge against the capital reserve to an increase in water rates.

The "water loss" factor was increased from 8% to 11%.

I asked; since the principle that water rates are not tax supported is clearly enunciated, are we equally fastidious about not including water used in tax supported services in rates charged to the consumer.

The answer was yes; departments are charged for water used.

Well, last week I asked for the number of the line item on the budget that shows charges for water. I had found an item for "utilities" which I understood was for gas and electricity.

The answer was : water use in particular facilities is combined and shows on a specific page of the budget as charged and settled.

Well, I gotta tell you. I went looking for that item. I didn't find it. Doesn't mean it isn't there. Just that my search skills are not that great. I don't know what that word "settled" means either.

But I did find the Water Rate Report and read that again.

In a paragraph defining "water loss" it said:

Fire department use. training and fire-fighting.

D'you remember;I didn't get a clear answer when I asked about that in the joint fire committee meeting. Newmarket's treasurer was at the table. He was conspicuous in his silence.

Unmetered supplies for landscaping, parks and road maintenance are also factored in as "water loss"

I don't know how much water is used for landscaping and parks and road maintenance. I do know it isn't "lost" It's used by departments which are tax supported services.

We have multiple parks and sports facilities. More every year. We have a splash pad in the town park. Nobody knows how much water it uses. It's not a trickle.

The water is not re-circulating. It goes straight down the drain. Sewer or storm? Dunno. But it makes a difference to how much we pay.

We create outdoor ice in the winter. A hose is kept running for days.That must take thousands of gallons. Norm Weller used to calculate the cost by man hours. Never mentioned anything about water.

We didn't have meters then.

The Region doesn't charge us by the thousands of gallons. They charge us by the gallon.

The Region by the way, notified municipalities of the increase on April 1st.We got the report at council on April 20th. We didn't deal with it until April 27th. Then it was urgent. Had to be done in time to be implemented by May 1st.

The Mayor was critical of my solitary negative vote.Scoffed at the politics of it. Said I should accept staff advice.

I don't know how many tanks of water, public works uses to wash streets. It doesn't matter. It's not water lost. It is a tax supported service.

The town's budget report notes the increase in taxes on an average house is $36. For perspective, a figure of 30cents a day is included. I hate that perspective.

The increase in water rates on an average household is $115. That means three times the increase for water than taxes.

There's reference to a future increase in rates for the capital reserve account for maintaining waterlines and such.

That has to mean the treasurer's change in accounting may not be as valid as first appeared.

If the money in the capital reserve to maintain water lines and such ,came from water rates in the first place, that is certainly where it should come from to pay for maintaining the water lines and such. Not from an increase in the rates

The report refers to old water meters not registering efficiently.

That may be so.

The only subdivision I know metered before the rest of the town, was Golf Glen.
In the greater scheme of things, that's a mere handful of homes. Meter slippage could easily be checked for "water loss". I doubt it amounts to much.

Now then..... I do not represent myself as an accountant. I don't even claim to be a competent book-keeper.

But I have to tell you, fellow tax and water-rate payers, I am not satisfied the town's water rates are calculated fairly or accurately.

They are certainly not meticulous.

We are paying for more than the water we use in our homes.How much more I don't know. But I believe it is not unsubstantial.

It's clear to me service costs which should be in the tax rate have been down-loaded to the water rate.

That's not straightforward book-keeping.

I believe as a Council, we have not done our due diligence.

Monday, 10 May 2010

It Took A While

Since three legal opinions have been provided that blog posts or letters to the editor cannot be added to a Council agenda without the permission of the writer.

We are also advised no question can be placed on an agenda, without due notice, a mover and a seconder or permission to suspend the Procedure Bylaw.

But ways have been contrived to get around all of that.

Councillor MacEachern, as chair, has placed or allowed, a letter to the editor on the agenda of a couple of meetings pf the Leisure Services Advisory Committee. Where it has been chewed over and members disaffection has been reported to Council.

Whereupon it became a matter of public record.

Councillor Gallo's Question of Privilege at the April 27th Council Meeting is an example of contriving to have content of a letter to the editor placed on a council agenda. Councillor Gallo's stated intention was to "correct the record"

A Question of Privilege is a means for a Councillor, who has been offended by a comment made in debate. He may feel he has been accused of wrongdoing,or a motive attached to a position he has taken in debate. The remedy is provided to request withdrawal of the offending comment and possibly receive an apology.

Refusal to withdraw or apologize are options. Which generally means the comments complained about stand.

The process permits an inadvertent error to be resolved without grievance. It is a necessary means of maintaining civility and reducing potential for personal animosity to grow within the council.

Huh!

The obligation to state one's position, without fear or favour, and the possibility of causing offence or being offended is an occupational hazard of politics.

The substance of Council Gallo's " Question of Privilege" was a letter to the editor. It was not part of "the record"

A Question of Privilege is introduced by a request from a member to the Chair to accept a Question of Privilege.

Following normal practice,the Chair directs the Member to state the question and rules on its acceptability.

Councillor Gallo's Question of Privilege was convoluted, clumsy and a contrived means of introducing a letter to the editor into the record. Not of correcting it.

A motion was made to receive the Question of Privilege as information.

Thereby making it part of the public record.

Taking time, in the face of such an egregious lack of comprehension of the rules , by both the member and the presiding member,would have been a waste of time.

Like so much that happens in Aurora Council, trying to untangle a tangle which has been so carefully tangled by so many hands beforehand, is a true exercise in frustration.

Council's Agenda is for the purpose of expediting town business.

Preparation is the responsibility of the Clerk. As is, keeping and maintaining records.

The Municipal Act defines it.

As it does the responsibility of elected members.

The Act requires at the beginning of each term, passage of a Procedure Bylaw, setting forth dates, times for the start and end of meetings. And publication of the Agenda beforehand.

The public must always be informed, what is to be decided at a particular meeting, within a particular time frame.

We have an Integrity Commissioner once again.

The first was hired , then fired after his first decision.

He did not find in favour of the complainants.

When the Commissioner receives a complaint, he is entitled to access records to establish validity.

Decisions of Council are required to be recorded without note or comment.

Blog posts and letters to the editor cannot be included on an agenda without the writer's consent.

The record of the April 27th 2010 Council Meeting of the Town of Aurora, is chock- a-block full of notes and comments and references to blog posts and letter to the editor.

It's the rule rather than the exception.

Readers may guess at the purpose of the intention.

Sunday, 9 May 2010

The Market is Growing

I hear thirty-six vendors have taken out permits.That's up from twenty-seven last year.

People don't always show up at the beginning and yesterday was a really terrible day.

The problem with permits wasn't at the town end.

The normal process is for applications to be received at the town and forwarded to the market committee to make sure they fit the profile of artisan and produce.

There was confusion about vendors plans to increase permit fees to cover the cost of hiring a manager.

Permit fees are town business. They are authorized by Bylaw.

A budget item was approved to hire a manager. The Bylaw to increase permit fees wasn't passed. No manager was hired.

Too many cooks I guess.

But there's a good feeling now that the vendors have taken control of their own affairs. There may even by opportunity for volunteer involvement. That's always a good thing .

The person who knows about accoutrements for the scooter wasn't at the store yesterday. I will have to see to that tomorrow.

A Significant Anniversary

It was May 12th 2009, Sher St.Kits came to council with a written presentation containing a variety of unfounded and unsubstantiated allegations against a Councillor, demanding Council take action and declaring her intention to file a complaint against said Councillor.

The Town Solicitor attempted on two occasions to intervene and advise the matter was not for Council to deal with.

The Mayor persisted.

Ms St Kitts was requested to provide her written comments to staff. .

A resolution was presented to suspend the Procedure Bylaw to permit Ms St Kitts' comments made in the public forum, to form part of the formal record.

There was a bit of a kefuffle about the two thirds requirement for suspension of the Procedure Bylaw.

The Mayor dealt with that too. She simply found the vote to be two thirds and declared the motion passed.

Two weeks later,May 26th 2009, Ms St. Kitts comments did not appear in the minutes presented for approval.

The minutes were challenged.

A review was requested.

And denied.

Unfounded and unsubstantiated accusations and allegations accepted in a public forum against a Member of Council, by the Mayor , against advice of the solicitor, despite a formal resolution of Council directing they be included in the formal record, were not.

The Chief Administrative Officer reported to Council; the solicitor , himself and the Clerk had conferred and decided "to follow precedent' and not record the full comments.

In response to public outcry and demands for explanation, the observation was made, in colloquial terms; "the minutes were doctored"

May 11th, 2010 Council Meeting , minutes of the April 27th, 2010 meeting are before Council for approval.

111. Open Forum

Ms Walmer ( the Mayor's friend and campaign organizer) spoke.

No motion was passed to suspend Procedure to allow the comments to form part of the public record.

No kefuffle about what constitutes a two-thirds majority.

No conference necessary between the Chief Administrator, solicitor or Municipal Clerk.

Yet there they are .

Twenty four lines . Every word recorded. In paragraphs yet. As if provided in writing.

No precedent followed.

No synopsis created.

A year almost to the day.

For a complete turn around and contradiction.

Who says minutes are not doctored to suit exigencies?

Pshaw! Let the record show.

Saturday, 8 May 2010

OH!!!! THE MARKET

It's 12 p.m. and I'm not there.

I was looking forward to tootling on up there on my scooter and spending a couple of hours perusing market wares.

But the skies are heavy. It has rained on and off .Thunder has rumbled now and then.

My scooter has no hood. And I can't stay on my feet to perambulate comfortably long enough to accomplish anything worthwhile.

Instead, I will shop for a hood and cover, so that I will not be similarly inconvenienced any time in the future.

I have in mind something like a "Surrey With Fringe on Top"

What are the chances, I will find something like that?

My daughter Theresa was at the Market. The vendors were folding up early because of the weather.

On Another Topic

I know no obligation to keep outrageous behaviour confidential.

Councillor Wilson on the other hand, apparently feels a room with closed doors is an opportunity not to be missed.

On Tuesday, during the in- camera meeting, he repeated a performance similar to one hurled at former Councillor Grace Marsh before she resigned.

On his feet, shouting, flailing his arms, he declared my "hatred" of the Mayor has destroyed everything this Council has tried to do throughout the term.

He bitterly excoriated things said about him in this blog.

There was a presiding member. The attack was permitted . There was an audience of staff. an external solicitor and the rest of Council.

It takes a better man than I am, not to respond to such an attack. And I did. Though not to my satisfaction.

Yet how does one?

Calmly, deliberately and with dignity, I might say:

Councillor, if you were not so fond of casting allegations,
accusations, sneers and jeers, there would surely be nothing
for me to say about you.
Our association is as Members of a Council.
We are not friends. We are not enemies.
Neither love nor hate have a place between us.
Our exchange is public business.
I will not engage at your level.
It fails to conform to any rules of order familiar to me.
Nor to your adopted Code of Conduct.
But I am not without resources.
The blog gives me a tool to respond.
You do it your way.I will do it mine.
People will judge how we handle ourselves in their name
Blog is a new element in politics but it's all grist for the mill, Councillor....
Grist for the mill.
If you do not like how I portray you, the solution is yours.
Stop doing and saying that which allows me to paint the portrait.
Stop fooling yourself into believing because there are six of you and you can make rules to suit your purpose, it means you have the upper hand.
I wasn't born yesterday, Councillor.
Don't think, I didn't learn a thing or five along the way.
I didn't survive because I was afraid to risk all for the sake of doing what I
thought was right.
Or my passion for being straighforward overcomes all else, including political
expediency.
I know well enough, it's not what people expect from a politician.
And it's not always a political advantage.
But it is what they need to expect from me. Because it's what I have and will
continue to give.

Well, of course. I didn't say any of those things. The ambiance was not conducive.

Instead my claws came out and I cut him a new one. It definitely made me feel better and I'm certainly not sorry.

But it did nothing to improve an appalling situation.

I am not hopeful anything can.

Let's Get Real

My daughter Heather came down yesterday. Our conversation was about the Special Olympics Floor Hockey Tournament she and Sue Hoey organised in Newmarket last Saturday.

Brent Hoey and Adam have been friends since starting school.Brent is a year or two younger

The Tournament hasn't been the only thing on the go. This week-end will be the first in eight months Heather has been free.

Many things needed to be done. Theresa and my grandson Rory were at the Ray Twinney Centre to do whatever.

Robyn and ten of her school-mates were in the kitchen on Friday baking four hundred cookies for lunch bags.They had great fun putting the lunches together with everything a person would like to find in a lunch.

The buns were ordered, fresh baked panini, from the Superstore. Everybody knows the difference when buns or bread is freshly baked.

There are no revenues for a Special Olympics Tournament. Every penny has to be squeezed twice.

The fee for the arena was $1270 for the day. That was a huge burden. Someone suggested a request to the Mayor.

The letter didn't get to the Mayor. Someone else had a meeting with the Mayor and mentioned the letter.

Immediately Mayor Tony Van Bynen forwarded $500. out of his golf tournament funds to reduce the fee.No publicity given, none sought.Only those who needed the help knew they got it
and from whence it came.

One of the things learned was how some people feel compelled to come forward and say they will do this or that. They don't. Then act as if they never offered.

And others who say " What do you need me to do" and come through like gang-busters.

Some parents have tears in their eyes, for sons and daughters having a chance to do something they never imagined possible.

Then there were kids from Owen Sound and Midland who came on a bus, without parents.

It was what it was With what there was to work with. At one and the same time a learning experience and a great success.

No tournament is ever organised without a tremendous weight on the shoulders of a few strong individuals.

The rest just need to stay out of the way

Adam dons a Town of Newmarket shirt and works at the arena one day a week.He is paid the union rate. His workmates gave that tournament their Royal Best.

Adam has friends from all Newmarket who know him from the arena.

Ray Twinney's heart would have been full, had he been there to see it.

It was a fitting tribute to his memory.

Thursday, 6 May 2010

HEIGH HO! TO THE MARKET WE WILL GO

On Saturday, May 7th at 8 a.m.

Aurora Farmers Market starts anew .

The Season is new but that's not all.

The Market, for the first time, will chart it's own course.

They will be independent of the town.

Free of exploitation .

They will show us their wares and cry ;

Who will buy .... Who will buy

We will hear their cry

And gather there for the sheer fun of it.

Click Forward

I forwarded the comment I received to the town and received the prompt response printed below.

I am obliged .

But I have to tell you what I miss:

I am accustomed to the clerk of the municipality providing smooth passage for the business of the corporation.

Items appear on the agenda in a timely manner for Council's attention. Bylaws are prepared on the direction of Council, before Council is even aware their direction is required.

The Clerk of the Municipality is the unseen hand that guides all things in smooth progression. Without the clerk given free rein and authority to do his/her job, chaos ensues.

Kind of like the wife and mother, who makes taking care of the multiple needs of the family look so easy everyone imagines no skill is involved.

We spent thousands of dollars on consultants to tell us how to re-organise the administration.

The Clerk's position in the administration was downgraded from number two to number four
.
Many of his responsibilities were transferred elsewhere.

We use a fraction of his skills and experience.

They are not replicated elsewhere.

On the other hand, the heavy and erratic hand of the Mayor is evident everywhere.

In Response To A Comment

In response to the inquiry, both Pet Value locations have now been provided with 2010 Pet Tags and are now selling them on behalf of the Town. Following the approval obtained from Council to enter into these agreements with the retail locations in April we finalized the agreements with the Legal Department and they were executed last week with the store owners and then signed by the Mayor and Town Clerk. Prior to this occurring I had been in contact with the store owners to advise them the agreements were coming allowing them to sell the pet tags. The front line employees at the store may not have been aware of this information.
All is now in place and the public can purchase the tags at both Pet Value locations.
I will follow-up with staff to ensure calls are properly transferred and directed to the appropriate person who is able to respond to the inquiry.


Legal Costs

On April 14th I once again sought, through proper channels, to obtain costs of the town's legal services for the years 2007/8/9/10.

I was informed they were being prepared and would be ready in two weeks. Three weeks later. Nothing .

Though costs are not available, we have recent experience of service provided.

On Tuesday, during Council in Committee, Mr. Roger Beaman,solicitor, arrived at the Town Hall between seven and eight o'clock.He was present for a consultation with Council in an in-camera meeting following Council in Committee.

Councillor Gallo was in the chair. He started the meeting on time and in good humour. He said he had made a bet with Councillor McRoberts, the meeting would be over in thirty minutes.

There were seven items on the agenda. Councillor Wilson indicated he wished to speak to six.

The meeting lasted an hour.

When I left the Town Hall at ten-thirty, Mr. Beaman was there still.

The solicitor's travel time would start when he left his office located on Bay Street. Consult time would likely be no less than three hours.

The question finally decided on Tuesday has been four times before Council in closed session. Mr. Beaman has been in attendance at least twice. Lengthy letters have also been submitted.

How many telephone conferences with the Mayor are unknown at this time.

I saw one on an invoice, at the beginning of the Westhill issue (March 2008) which lasted fifty minutes The time drew my attention.

I remember thinking..... Oh My God, that was a $475 conversation.

I think that may be the rationale that legal invoices have not been made available to me...or anyone else.

The first time Tuesday's agenda item was on the table, Council had received a letter providing three options for way and means of reimbursing opposing neighbours for their expenditures to seek a consolidated board hearing to protect their interest.

We were informed the residents had decided, after three unsuccessful proceedings , to abandon their quest. As they had a right to do. As they had a right to start it Separate and independent of the Municipality to defend their private interest.

It was not our business to know.

I made it clear then in my opinion, the item had no business being discussed behind closed doors. The Town has a policy for considering grant applications. It does not provide for secret deliberation.

I said so publicly at the time. I have said so since.

The matter has subsequently morphed into something other than a grant application. I have not been persuaded.

On Tuesday night, at the table, were two solicitors; the town solicitor and Mr. Beaman. The Chief Administrative Officer was present also and the Municipal Clerk as recording secretary.

Much of the meeting was taken up with matters other than the issue on the agenda. Disorderly, mildly describes the proceedings. Degrading for all present is without exaggeration.

In staff reports to Council, there's a section which refers to Financial Impact:

I believe the financial tally for this particular exercise was thousands, possibly, tens of thousand of dollars.

Time spent on Tuesday in totally reprehensible and chaotic disorder, with the clock ticking and the tally mounting was of no benefit to any person present.

To argue service to the community is without merit or integrity.

Wednesday, 5 May 2010

ON A BREACH OF TRUST

I was home last night in time for Becker and David Letterman. I was so glad to see the conflicted New York City, store front doctor and his zany friends. They certainly help to put things into perspective

Aurora's General Committee meeting started at 7p.m. Ended an hour later. Then the real fun began. It was the fourth session on the same issue. That's how long it took for the Mormac twins to get the decision they wanted.

You won't know about it for another two weeks. The Mayor wants to "see what happens" in the meantime.

Things are definitely becoming frayed to the point of frenzy around the edges.

Considerable time was spent discussing my blogs and confidentiality.They were not items on the agenda.

There were two lawyers on hand. They didn't talk about blogs.

The Procedural Bylaw and Code Of Conduct were referenced.

Well, you should have seen the conduct. Not much there to commend the Code.

If I ever had any illusion that code was intended as an instrument for good, I would certainly have lost it last night.

I snapped after about ninety minutes and said a bad word.

If I were still at the Age of Reason, I would certainly have a sin to confess.

But not a crime.

TO MARKET!!!!!!!!!!!!! TO MARKET

Aurora Farmers' Market starts on Saturday at the Town Park at 8 a.m. on Wells Street.

Vendors have made their permit applications and paid their fees. There's a bottleneck . As of today, permits are not yet issued.

There has been no advertising because the Mayor's favourite volunteer quit.

Councillor Stephen Granger, the Mayor's Council Liaison Appointee has also terminated his connection.

For the moment, The Farmers' Market is at sixes and sevens.

But never fear. They will rally and be better than ever this year.

All the better for being independent.

Starting Saturday, a favourite summer ritual will commence again at 8 a.m. on Wells Street. in front of the beautiful old school building, at the Town Park in Aurora.

Come One!!!!!!! Come All!!!!!!!!!

Enjoy a piece of the past and The Select Purveyors of the Aurora Farmer's Market

By Appointment to the Good People of Aurora

All other Aurora blogs please copy

I Digressed

An alternate term for Breach of Confidentiality, is Breach of Trust.

It's a Criminal Offense. Charges can be laid under the Criminal Code of Canada.

A charge is not a conviction. A judge makes that determination after listening to legal arguments.

But first, a determination has to be made by the appropriate official about intent and impact and the merits of laying a charge.

I do not claim proficiency in law. I have the same sense of logic and fairness as any other citizen. In addition,I have experience acquired over many years as an elected official.

I am as capable as any of determining public interest.

It is as follows;

In matters of litigation, the town takes legal advice. From time to time,Council must give authority for certain steps to be taken. Councillors must be informed. Conveying such information to a party litigating against the town is a Breach of Public Trust.

It might be inadvertence.

It might be mischief.

It might be information traded in consideration of financial exchange.That's the baddy

Whatever the reason, if the town's interest is compromised, a person could be found to be in Breach of Trust.

********************************************

Two other aspects of town business qualify for confidentiality.

The first is individual right to privacy .

The second, labour negotiations.

Bargaining in good faith is required by law.

If Council gave authority to an hourly rate increase between two figures and a Councillor conveyed the figures to a union representative, the municipality's interest would be compromised.

That would be a Breach of Trust.

*************************************

In the matter of individual right to privacy:

If an employee is terminated and decides to sue for unfair dismissal. The issue of course becomes the subject of litigation.

A Councillor may become possessed of particular details.

Under Rights to Privacy and because of litigation or potential litigation, the municipal interest may be doubly compromised by public release of details detrimental to the employee
or conversely, detrimental to the interest of the municipality.

That would be a Breach of Trust.

****************************************

There's nothing complicated about the principles.

Most people, in their daily lives, have to make decisions about their own , their family or their business interest. As citizens of a society long governed by law, we have an intuition about what is right and just. Common Law is based on exactly that.

What we have to look out for in municipal politics are decisions made behind closed doors that do not belong there

A closed door session used improperly for the purpose of suppressing the public decision-making process, I think, is a Breach of Public Trust as surely as all the rest.

Tuesday, 4 May 2010

More About Water Rates

Yesterday's post was rough at the edges. More needs to be told. Few around when the Region was created, are still here to tell the tale.

Before Region, we had our own wells .Numbers of them . Water used by town departments was minimal.

The Town Hall was an old bank building on Yonge Street. We had less than a half -dozen people on staff there.

One toilet upstairs and one down served the needs.

The works department was a couple of battered and rusty old quanset huts on Wellington Street. There would be a toilet or two in there and I'm pretty sure, a shower of sorts.

We had one community centre with maybe three full-time staff and a bunch of rink rats.

There were probably more toilets and showers there than anywhere. They weren't much used on weekdays.

We had a traffic court in the auditorium ,with a magistrate,cops and various other miscreants from ten to four during the week.

We had the Firehall. They had a room at the back which, I discovered years later, was a bit of a watering hole for various people in the know. The Fire Chief was the only full-time person on the payroll.

Water was ours. We found it. We pumped it. We treated it. We created reservoirs. We distributed it.

The flat rate was so low, it hardly seemed worth sending out bills every three months. So they went out with hydro bills. We owned that too.

Revenue paid all costs and provided a stash to fund whatever small projects came along. Like an extra bay on the firehall. Money was borrowed from the reserve and paid back with interest.

Things were so beautifully simple. We only had three parks.I don't know if even schools were billed for water use. We owned them too. When students and staff were using facilities in the schools ,they weren't using them at home.

In those days, people who worked for the town, lived in the town.

When the region was created things didn't change right away. Ownership of wells was
transferred, But they were still the same wells and the same people using the water. We still had a flat rate user fee though it increased substantially.

When the new firehall was built, a weir was built on the creek to allow that water to be used for fire practice. I don't know if they're still doing that. We have a joint fire service with Newmarket. I mentioned it at fire committee last week but didn't get a straight answer.

But since then, My Goodness, how things have changed.

We have swimming pools. Numbers of them.

A summer ice facility at the Aurora Leisure Complex uses hundreds of thousands of litres of water daily for the cooling system. In the beginning, there was tin roof and the system worked overtime to accomplish its function. Then the roof was insulated. It still uses horrendous amounts of water, which still clean, is dumped into the sewer system and we pay for it to be treated as sewage.

We have a splash pad in the town park. I don't know if anyone knows the water consumption for that facility.But it certainly is substantial and more than before.

We have miles more streets to be washed. Hydrants to flush to keep pipes clean and clear. Dozens, maybe even hundreds of vehicles to be washed. Toilets flushing constantly in town facilities all over . The Mayor's office suite has a beautiful washroom facility complete with shower.

When I was Mayor, I had a room in the old town hall. A previous Mayor had rousted out a desk from storage and brought in an old carpet from the Queen's Hotel, his home on the north east corner of Yonge and Wellington.

I had to vacate every time the Clerk-Administrator needed it for a private meeting.

The Clerk's office had room for a desk ,two chairs and a filing cabinet .Some days you'd be hard-pressed to find him behind the stacks of papers on his desk.

It was within feet of Yonge Street and the papers would have a film of dust and black sooty specks . The stack on the file cabinets reached almost to the ceiling.

Preparing for an election, every year and then every two, battered metal ballot boxes would be scattered around . We literally had to climb over them to get around .

It was the norm. Nobody noticed the inconvenience.

Anyway, I know some town buildings are currently metered.

The question is, does the town bill itself for water used in tax-supported facilities and services? Or do we continue the practice of years ago.....when wells were ours.... flat rate charged to consumers was minimal ....and water used by the town was infinitesimal...and wasn't worth measuring?

Do we take the Region's charge for total consumption of water and simply calculate from that rates sufficient to foot the region's bill ?

That is not honest. People believe they are paying only for the water they use.They are encouraged to conserve.

When I asked the question, the answer was fuzzy. Like.... "there's an averaging factor".

Well I'm not sure that's good enough. I don't re-call any debate to signal a change. I would have noticed that.

There has to be a reason, besides size and population, why Richmond Hill's rate is hundreds of dollars a year less than our own.

When the answer is forthcoming, I will pass it on.

I just thought of something weird. I am asking questions I have never heard asked before.

I know how things were. I don't know for sure how they are.

Did the process for calculating water rates change with steadily increasing use of water by town departments ?

Or was it just not thought about?

Is the use still so insignificant it doesn't need to be thought about?

Does town staff have responsibility only to ensure sufficient funds are collected in water rates to pay the bill?

As they do in tax rates

Or when they state, water rates are not tax supported... are they not also obliged to ensure water rates do not subsidise tax rates?

Is it Council's responsibility, in a year when water rates increased by 12%, to look closer and make sure people are being fairly charged?

I think the questions are reasonable. I am one of nine. Why am I the only one interested in the
answers?

Monday, 3 May 2010

Bafflegab and Water Rates

To coin the crude and the vernacular, I think we're being screwed on water rates.

I don't have proof positive yet but I'm working on it.

Your next water bill will reflect a 12% increase.

I don't think that's right.

You need to know what I know.

First,York Region is responsible for the supply of water.They sell it to us at a wholesale price.
I'm not challenging their calculations. Not yet.

Second, water is taken from the ground. . It's not like coal,oil,.copper,diamonds or gold. We take what we need.We use it. We treat it. We return it to its source.

Water is pumped from the deep dark recesses of the ground. It's stored,treated and distributed . Water doesn't cost money. All that other stuff does.

Before meters, a flat rate was charged to every household for water. It came out with the hydro bill. I don't think it ever went much beyond $9.95 every quarter.

As little as it was, we were able to pump, store,treat and distribute fresh.cold.spring water,
to homes in Aurora, pay whatever it cost and still grow a water reserve account.

When I was Chair of the Fire Committee, we had to build an extra bay on the fire station. I think it cost $18.thousand dollars. We borrowed it from the Water Reserve Account.

It was the only reserve we had.

Sewage treatment was on the general levy.

Water meters were installed for the purpose of charging for sewage treatment.

Now the bill also includes the cost to collect rain from roofs and roads in new subdivision and to store it in ponds, for God's sake.

It's a far cry from the cost of water.

Not all water we use goes into the sanitary sewers. But we pay a sewage rate for it just the same.

Water used in the garden, car-washing, topping up the pool,or any other outdoor purpose goes through the water meter and gets charged as a sewer rate.

The Chief Financial Officer told us last week , the region allows for that in the calculation of rates.

I do not recall ever seeing an explanation in the water bill to that effect.

I am not able to accept it.

And that's not all I am unable to accept.


*******************************************

A presentation by the Treasurer was made in Council last Tuesday to explain the double digit increase in the water bill.

It started with the premise, water is not a tax supported service. .

We all know that.

For accurate application of the principle however , the user pays only for water used by the user.

*****************************************************************

First, the Region has increased water rates by ten per cent. That is not within our control.

Second, all regional municipalities pay the same for water.

Not all charge the same rate to consumers.

Why is our rate different to Richmond Hill's rate?

Why is our rate the same as the Town of Newmarket

*********************************************************

Last Tuesday, I attended a joint Fire Services Committee. An Officer referred to water and a Regional agreement.

I seized the opportunity to ask if water used by the fire department is billed to the fire department.

My thought was, water is not tax supported and that is an accepted principle.

But fire protection is tax supported.

Is the cost of water used by the fire department shown in the cost of providing that service or is it somehow folded in to water rates not supported by taxes but charged to consumers?

We have a new fire chief. Newmarket's CAO was at the table. The Deputy Chief ,who prepares the budget was there. And Newmarket Treasurer.

It was established most fires are extinguished with water from the tanker. The tanker is filled at the station. The station is metered.

It was not established that the cost of water used is reflected in the department's budget.We heard from several at the table.

The Treasurer did not volunteer any information.

******************************************

In his presentation to Council that evening, Aurora Treasurer explained that for better accounting he and the Public Works Director had, during their budget preparation, removed $250 thousand, expenditure normally charged against a capital reserve account for maintenance of a capital asset and transferred it to user water rates.

That was before the year end. I do not remember that item being pin-pointed.That's what happens when a change is made.

It decreased the tax rate and five months later, it contributed to a double digit increase in water rates.

In conjunction with public works director, it was also decided to increase estimated "water loss" from 8% to 12%.

"Water loss" they claim, is from "seepage" in the system. Water used in fire practice was mentioned.

The Treasurer explained Provincial requirements for water treatment have increased since Walkerton and that contributed to the increased cost of water .

Walkerton happened ten yeasr ago. . I know bafflegab when I hear it. God knows I've heard enough of it.

When meters were introduced the figure for "water loss" was 4%,I think. Since then, many miles of new waterlines have been installed ,old lines have been re-placed and others re-lined.

That's not a reason for an increase in " water loss" If anything it should accomplish the opposite.

The question about various tax supported services , such as fire department, works department, parks department, town hall, reflecting water consumption in their budgets was answered in the affirmative.

Yet I have no recollection of ever seeing water as a budget item reflected in any department's budget.

We also heard that water revenue decreased last year. It was a wet summer. Consumption was down. A deficit in revenue was likely but not mentioned as the need to increase water rates this year.

********************************************************

I voted against the water rate increase. Just me, myself,alone. Again.

I don't believe the year the region increased the water rate by ten per cent is the year to change book-keeping in a capital reserve account for maintenance of a capital asset to be added to an increase in non tax supported water rates

I don't believe it is the year to increase the estimate of "water loss"

Which I suspect is a misnomer.

I believe the budget item number to prove water use is reflected in the budgets of tax supported services should have been produced immediately the question was asked,to support the statement they are in fact included .

I do not accept justification to charge consumers in Aurora, several hundred dollars more for water than consumers in Richmond Hill, which municipality pays exactly the same for water as we do.

As a representative of the consumer in Aurora, I think we are being royally screwed in the matter of water rates.

I will be happy to be proven wrong.

Sunday, 2 May 2010

The Figure asked For

I have on occasion posted political on the personal blog. Any time I've done that. I've needed
Heather Sisman to switch it for me. Well today I did it myself. I cut and pasted successfully once again.

I also have the cost of the ad that ran on the April 15Th edition of The Banner.It cost $3,700 for both pages. exclusive of GST. I calculate that at $455. The total therefore would have been in excess of $4,000.

In the ebb of a four year term, within weeks of an election campaign, I think public
perception could easily be, the ad is promoting incumbent politicians rather than the town.

No fair No fair.

Posted by Evelyn Buck at 3:36 PM

A New Element

I received an e-mail yesterday from a resident who watched part of the council meeting on Tuesday.He watched it again on -line with Rogers on Wednesday. He wanted to assure me my hearing was correct.

To the second, he gave me the time Councillor Gallo made the statement that he wanted to correct the record against my comments about the Mayor's appointment to committees.

Again to the second, my correspondent gave me the time the Councillor denied having made that reference..

I tried to copy and paste the e-mail this morning to show it in the Blog. This time I blew it and lost the whole thing. It isn't even in my delete box.

So...I am not as smart as I thought I was. Oh well.

My objective is not to prove perfidy. I've already established Councillor Gallo is taking direction from the wrong teachers. He will have to learn that for himself . He has chosen the hard way. It will be at his cost.

I wanted to show the e-mail because I think it's such a positive sign that people are becoming evermore actively involved . I think blogs and the opportunity to engage without risk is the reason.

We have always been able to cast a ballot in secret. Now we can talk about politics anonymously and let it rip. I think that's great. It may be the element needed to make democratic politics real and not just a philosophical idea. The new element may not yet have reached it's full potential. But I think it's getting there.Fast.

Paul, if you are reading this post, please send me a copy of the e-mail. It may be somewhere in ether-ether land still but I haven't a clue how to find it.

We had a vote on Tuesday to increase the water rates by 12%. I am not satisfied that amount of increase was necessary. Every municipality in the Region is paying the same rate to the Region. But the rate charged to consumers is not the same. Richmond Hill's rate is a couple of hundred dollars less than ours.

Our Chief Financial Officer informed us water rates are not tax supported. That means the user pays what it cost. In answer to my question, he also stated water used by various tax-supported services like works, parks and fire is charged to each department's budget. I do not re-call any discussion about a 10% increase for water in department budgets.

On Saturday, my task will be to scrutinise the budget with a friend to verify that we are not charging water used by tax supported services to non-tax supported rates to consumers..

If we are using water rates to reduce tax rates I want to know so that I can tell you about it.

Since the increase has already passed by your Council there's no hope of changing it.

That makes it an election issue.

Posted by Evelyn Buck at 2:58 PM 0 comment

I Went to a Marvelous Party

I Went to a Marvelous Party

The Blessing of St. Maximilian Kolbe Separate High School on Wellington Street, Aurora. It's the first one of those I have ever attended.

The evening was crammed full of unexpected images. I have to go back on my scooter for a proper tour.

But Oh My...It started at 7 p.m; a brilliant and bright celebration in every sense of the word.

Elizabeth Crowe, trustee for Aurora, King and Whitchurch- Stouffville and Chairman of the Board shared honours with Trustee Theresa McNicol of Newmarket.

When the site plan came forward to this Council for approval, incredibly a majority expressed opposition.

The land had had to be quietly assembled for the board to arrive at the point of processing a site plan. Had Council refused it, months of delay would have ensued and legal costs for the Town and the Board, all coming out of the same pocket.

Two public bodies, accountable to the same taxpayers, would have undoubtedly locked in a dispute before the Ontario Municipal Board, an outside and separate body of jurisdiction.

Councillor Gaertner had most to say.

It would be too great a burden on the town's taxpayers.No tax revenues would be derived.

A full complement of teaching, support and custodial jobs were dismissed as insignificant and not an asset to the town's economy.

How did the school board know there were enough students to justify the school ?

Where would students come from? Didn't some come from out of town? The Councillor sounded like she wanted to see the figures to be satisfied the board was making the right decision.

It was before the possibility Dr.G.W.Williams High School being closed was on the radar. When the same Councillor presented the reverse argument.

Then the business community in that neighbourhood would be devastated by loss of the school

Students and teachers were a great asset to the economic well-being of that neighbourhood. Susan Walmer was all set to lead the charge on that issue.

That was after the opportunity to sell a parcel of land to the Region for Police Headquarters with seven hundred well paid jobs in the 404 area had been turned down.

For the same reason. It would be too great a burden on the taxpayers.

When the Separate High School crisis happened, the whole burden lay on the shoulders of Elizabeth Crowe, trustee for three communities. She was not Chairman at that time.

She rallied parents, who chose spokespersons from every separate school in town to address Council and speak to the issue of need. Father Don MacLean , Our Lady of Grace parish priest came with them to lend his support and gave expression to the meaning of the school to Catholic parents.

They made the difference. The vote shifted.

Councillor MacEachern noted her daughter attends Cardinal Carter High School. The Mayor recalled she had attended a Catholic school.

Councillor Gaertner's arguments were suddenly irrelevant.

No doubt exists in my mind , were it not for the effort of School trustee Elizabeth Crowe ,
the beautiful new High School on Wellington Street, Aurora would not be.

As it stands in all it's splendid function, a distinct attribute to this community, it is a credit to the leadership of one small very determined woman who never lost sight of the main objective.

What Kind Of A March Was That

Yesterday, at a march to legalise marijuana. a man was critically injured when he fell out of a tree.

I have heard of various effects of smoking pot. But marching up a tree is new.

In the same edition of the paper, a headline referred to the charmed life of a tree whisperer. But it was a different story.

The best item was by Christopher Hume. His column generally deals with the living city. This one referred to the illusion that Toronto is a progressive city.

He says municipal councillors have made whole careers out of pandering to every last nimby impulse local residents can muster.

He called Rob Ford and Rocco Rossi "nattering nincompoops of nonsense" They are candidates for the office of Mayor of Toronto.

He said Mel Lastman's great contribution was to leave the budget in tatters and embarrass the city on network television at every turn.

But the Toronto media, of which Hume is a part, largely commended former Mayor Lastman
when he left office undefeated.

It was the phrase " nattering nincompoops" that caught my attention.

The incredible fact is, Rob Ford is, according to polls, running second in the mayoralty contest

It doesn't mean he will be the next Mayor just that, nattering nincompoop of nonsense notwithstanding, , he could be the next Mayor of the Toronto

If we compare that with our situation, we find distinct similarities.

Pandering definitely is the main modus of operandi. We do have a Number One Nimby with followers;

And despite Mr. Hume's mocking reference,confidence abounds, that pandering is sound and the only way to win votes and influence people.

Anyone who dares to challenge the theory is tilting at windmills and must be punished with penalties yet.

Can all these experienced municipal politicians be wrong?

Will "the nattering nincompoops of nonsense" win the prize in October?

Sometimes I think ....Nah!

Other times, when I listen, I think..... Oh My God, maybe!

Who's going to stop it?

Then I think of the missing factor.

Pandering is undeniable and prominent at all levels of politics

As long as leadership is the missing factor, pandering will continue to fill the bill.

Saturday, 1 May 2010

In Terms Of History

The separate school board has had the right to build complete high schools for about thirty years.

When the law changed in Ontario, they started slow. They converted elementary schools. My daughter Heather went to St. Roberts in Markham . After Grade Ten, she wanted to go to Williams because private school fees were required at St Robert's.

After a few weeks, she was utterly miserable. Sheer size and numbers at Williams had completely overwhelmed her'

I don't think any institution is improved by enormity..I think it becomes dehumanized.

Heather went back to St Roberts.

When I finished writing about St. Max on Friday, I thought about how a public school supporter parent might feel about such a school being built in Aurora but not available to their children.

Then I remembered. Sue Walmer and her "organisation" went to battle to ensure it wouldn't.

When the public board was contemplating location of a new high school. the horns blared with the call to mount the ramparts to challenge the board's authority..

The Mayor, completely in character, immediately engaged and the council chamber was made available to accommodate opposition hordes to assemble and plan the campaign.

The issue was on the board's front burner because they have to make the need for a site known when development is being planned.

Arguments presented against a new school were opposite to the arguments against a new separate high school just weeks before.

Except for the lament about heritage and tradition which, in the context of education. I frankly find extraordinary.

Sue Walmer, as I said led the charge. She took CAO John Rogers to task for failing to act in making the Council Chamber available.A Council decision is required. Ms Walmer is completely confident in her supervisory role in Town affairs.

Mayor Morris inferred the town would block any attempt by the board to sell the Williams site for development. The Mayor is equally confident of her autocratic authority..

Oh....the majesty of it all.

Except maybe for police facilities which function twenty-four- seven, , nothing is as hard-worn as a school. It acquires an odor. A mixture of lunch boxes ,chalk,running shoes ,sweat , winter outerwear,exercise togs and hormone-driven youth.

People who complained about odour in the change rooms of the Aurora Community
Centre have a sense of it.

But Walmer and Morris, like a Punch and Judy Show, promptly beat upon the heads of board trustees for even thinking of such a thing.

They may not have won the battle. The school board still has a worn out building that costs hundreds of thousands to maintain and provides few of the facilities required for a modern education.

They still have a vastly expanded future student population to plan for and a decision pending

They may, like everyone else, be waiting for the next election to be over, when decisions can be made without Meddling Messrs Morris and Walmer on the scene ever-ready for combat.

The Dunning Avenue school site is worth millions which would go a long way to providing funding for a new school in a new location with all the space needed.

It would provide for housing envisaged by the Province for "infilling" to reduce urban sprawl.

Which in turn would provide passengers for a rapid transit system.

Which would reduce pollution by taking cars of the road.

Which would fulfill Aurora's commitment to environmental protection so oft cited by none other than Messrs Morris and Walmer

Oh yes, let's not forget Councillor Gaertner and MacEachern in the phony baloney
histrionics that represent Aurora's politics.

But more than anything, it would provide opportunity for public school students to enjoy facilities that would generate new enthusiasm and commitment of parents and staff and students to their future, their community and their world.

At the opening of the refurbished Church Street School, MLA Frank Klees received the only real applause of the evening. When he said we need to do the same thing with Wells Street there was a shout of laughter and the people there came to life. .

I thought, .what is the matter with these people that they can only get excited about musty, malodorous , mouldy, worn-out, relics of the past.

Friday, 30 April 2010

I Haven't Finished With My Impressions

St.Max opened last September. They are coming to the end of their first year. Only Grade Nine and Ten were in operation last year. Each year a Grade will be added.

On Tuesday we had a chance to see results of one year.

Two girls, not more than sixteen, if that, rendered several songs with complete professional composure

.A young man who needed support to stand, sang Ave Maria.

A Grade nine student played a Chopin piece...you know... waterfall music.

A grade nine class performed a dance interpretation of Life before the Nazis, life in death camps, the Saint's ministry to his fellow prisoners and his death .

There was an incredibly, graceful and professional interpretive dance by Grade Nine girls.

Come to think of it,I'm not really sure if that was Grade Nine or Ten, no matter, it was incredible.

The Arts are a part of the phys. ed department. They have a dance studio.

As far as I could see. and in accordance with my limited awareness. the stage is fully equipped for dramatic productions.

A manufacturing process is part of the school curriculum.

They have White boards throughout the school.

Workshop programs are available to all of the students.

I am not aware the Separate School system has ever offered Continuing Education Courses
and I don't know what would be involved but it boggles the mind to think of what might be possible.

In the Catholic school system, students with different abilities are not segregated. I saw a younger dark-haired edition of my grandson Adam participating with his peers. I knew he would be there.

Sports facilities are already underway and some are completed. They hope to have a football team next year.

The Separate School system has a record of sharing facilities with the community.

Aurora. we should be taking note of what we have here and what new opportunities are possible.

This was a celebration we can all share.

Thursday, 29 April 2010

A Special Guest

Max Eisen was a special guest at the High School Blessing and Opening Celebration. He was identified on the program as an Auschwitz Survivor.He was an inmate in 1944.

Father Maximillian Kolbe was a Franciscan priest, also an inmate of Auschwitz who was executed there in 1941. He gave his life in place of another's . Of Mr. Eisen's family of 65 members almost all were executed in 1944.

A group of students and staff of the high school went to Poland and France last year to learn what they could of the man whose life is commemorated in the spirit of their school.Mr Eisen had helped them understand how things were in Auschwitz.

I was not able to watch that part of the video. I have vivid memories of what the allies found in the death camps when the war ended. The images will haunt me as long as I live.

Father Lucian, also a guest,was a colleague of St Maximilian Kolbe. He spoke of him as a brother. Of his scholarly intelligence. Of his interest in science. How he embraced the modern media of his time and thereby attracted Gestapo attention to himself.

I have never met anyone who knew a Saint. I don't even know anyone who has. I have no doubt he was everything they said he was.

Yet the message Father Lucian brought to the students from the saint was simple.

Love...Love your neighbour.

The auditorium was full of students, parents, teachers, two parish priests and a Bishop gathered together to make a joyful commitment, to their faith , their future, their community and their world.

The evening, the school, the ceremony, certainly made the connection for me between the evil that was The Holocaust and school in a small Town in Canada, thousands of miles distant and a mere seventy years apart.

I personally expect great things of St Maximilian Kolbe Separate High School on Wellington Street, Aurora.

Cost of The Ad

I have on occasion posted political on the personal blog. Any time I've done that. I've needed
Heather Sisman to switch it for me. Well today I did it myself. I cut and pasted successfully once again.

I also have the cost of the ad that ran on the April 15Th edition of The Banner.It cost $3,700 for both pages. exclusive of GST. I calculate that at $455. The total therefore would have been in excess of $4,000.

In the ebb of a four year term, within weeks of an election campaign, I think public
perception could easily be, the ad is promoting incumbent politicians rather than the town.

No fair. No fair.

Springtime and Mayhem in Ukraine

Last week, on international news, we saw Ukraine Parliamentarians throwing eggs and other non-lethal stuff at each other. Similar events have been caught on camera in a Japanese Legislative Assembly.

Members there were climbing over desks and reaching for a throat to throttle.

It doesn't happen under British Parliamentary Rules of Order . The objective there of course is to maintain civility at all costs. As in a court room.

Tuesday night was mayhem in Aurora.It started with Councillor Gallo raising a Question of Privilege.

The Councillor's Question was a letter of mine to an editor which set out how committees are chosen in the Mormac regime.

A Question of Privilege allows a Councillor to object to his motives having been impugned or of being accused of wrong doing during a council debate.

The Question must be raised immediately the offending comment is made, or at the start of the next meeting before any other business has been conducted. Expectation is, the comment will be withdrawn and an apology offered. All very civilized.

Councillor Gallo's Question of Privilege was not apt. I expect he was advised by the presiding Member and her terrible twin, Councillor MacEachern.

Councillor Gallo is earnestly trying to acquire the skills necessary to function with ease in Council debate. Unfortunately, he has chosen the wrong teachers.

It was an evening of repeated similar attempts to call me to task. Councillor Gaertner did something equally inapt

Then there was a letter from Rebbecca Beaton stating my formal motion of request for re-consideration of a previous council decision was shameful.

I've known Rebbecca since she was a toddler.She grew up on my street. Went to school with my children.

There have to be icons in her life. She tags along willing to provide whatever support her patrons may require of her.

When I read her letter, it reminded me of Mister Wilson's conduct before he became a Councillor and after. I had taken the last seat at the table in his second bid for office. Rebecca used to sit beside him in the darkened back row of seating in the Council Chamber.

Wilson would descend to take the podium in public forum and heap abuse on my head, his voice rising to a hysterical shriek as his outrage grew.

The first time he did it I waited for the Mayor to put a stop to it. He didn't. I told the Mayor, no citizen has a right to behave like that in the Council Chamber.

It is disorderly conduct.

He repeated the behaviour.. Again the Mayor did not stop him. I told the Mayor , if you let him do that one more time I will not be responsible for how I will respond.

Next time he started , the Mayor stopped him. But Councillors Vrancic and Keane also thought a citizen had the right to behave that way.

It takes two to start a brawl. Once it starts, there's no telling where it will end.

It was Mayor Morris's turn on Tuesday to insist a citizen has a right to verbally attack an elected representative in a formal meeting of Council within the Council Chamber.

Of course she is wrong. Her ignorance knows no depth.

No-one has that right in a civilized society.

But since this presiding member makes up the rules as she goes along and as it suits her, the options for a Councillor are few.

A brawl is the most likely.

It will not be this Councillor who turns Aurora Council Chamber into a mud-wrestling pit.

Still ....I am not completely without resources.

But Rebbecca Beaton is not likely to be the target.

I suspect the Mayor and her terrible cohort Councillor Evelina MacEachern urged it upon her to write the offending comment.

The attack was personal but not made in person . Rebecca knows me. She might very well expect a vigorous response to a gratuitous insult.

I cannot imagine why anyone would think it's safe to attack this politician in a public meeting.

Wednesday, 28 April 2010

Ten Best Signs

I left Council at the hour of adjournment last night three hours and thirty minutes after the start.

The Mayor was putting on a slide show of seemingly permanent blighted sites down town and re-writing history as she went. Apparently Her Worship and a Department head or three took a conspicuous photographic tour to create a record, so that Councillors and the home audience could become aware of how bad things are in down town Aurora and what the Mayor is doing single handed to correct the situation.

I had asked immediately prior to the presentation about a massive coloured advertisement from the Town of Aurora that appeared a couple of weeks ago in a local newspaper. I queried who authorized it, what was its purpose and how much it cost.

The Chief Administrator claimed responsibility and said its purpose was to show how good things are in the Town of Aurora. He did not know off the top of his head, how much it cost

I was home in time to watch David Letterman. Some nights he's better than others but last night I particularly enjoyed his show.

A regular feature of the program is Ten Best Signs. Last night, they were Signs Your Neighbour is An Alien.

I thought....sipping on my single malt, with ice, no water, a gift from my son....I could do that. It could be... Ten Best Signs Five Councillors and a Mayor have a hate on for Evelyn Buck.

The possibilities are endless. I would need a tape of last night's meeting.

Ten Best Signs Mayor Morris is out of her depth. . Tina Fey would be perfect casting.. Sarah Palen's line still gets a laugh. "I can see Russia from my house" to illustrate her depth of foreign policy awareness.

Sue Walmer's character could be featured as Champion of her beloved leader and all that is pure and virtuous and if it's land abutting yours, keep it idle in perpetuity.

I had an inquiry at the week-end. At a silent auction for a cancer fundraiser a Certificate for a Splash Pass at a town facility was an item. Donor was Mayor Morris. My correspondent wondered if that should have been the Town of Aurora.

I asked. The Town's Parks and Recreation department have a policy of providing certificates, value $40. for charitable causes.

The request for a donation was funneled through the Mayor's office.

My inquirer was correct, the donation to the charity should have been credited to the Town of Aurora.

Monday, 26 April 2010

New Evidence

Three years ago , an anonymous letter was placed in each Councillor's box . It bore no date stamp for incoming mail, however delivered. The Clerk said it had been received at the Mayor's office and brought across to the Clerk's department. .

The Councillors room is secure. No-one can gain entry without the little do-hickey that does the open- sesame thing. Only Councillors and staff have access.

The letter was six pages long and full of hate. My experience and age were a specific target.

Colleagues felt it should not be ignored. An R.C.M.P. officer informally reviewed it and deemed it " incitement to hatred"

I forwarded it to Chief Armand La Barge and an officer attended on the Clerk. The nature of the letter was not disputed but tracking its source was next to impossible.Also "incitement to hatred" is an offence in only certain circumstances.

The letter, if not written, had certainly been distributed by a Councillor.

Mr. Wilson's frequent personal attacks in the public forum during the previous term of Council made him a likely possibility.

I referred to the letter publicly. Councillor MacEachern denied either she or Councillor Gaertner were responsible. I believed that. Councillor MacEachern is famous for her vituperative style of self- expression but she always signs her name.

Recipients of the Councillor's insults compared notes and established her most spectacular missives were usually dispatched around midnight... the witching hour.

At 8.31 p.m. on Sunday, Councillor Wilson sent an e-mail to Mayor Morris, copied to Councillors and the Chief Administrative Officer, expressing similar sentiments to the anonymous letter.

Authorship is no longer in doubt.

Councillor Wilson's unhappiness with my conduct continues. He is confident however the good work of Council to improve the Town is recognized and appreciated.

The following is an exert:

even with years of experience there can be a complete lack of understanding
of how to effectively deal with issues and conduct one's self in the 21st
century.

This consistent style of negativity and conflict while directed at staff as
'the punching board' is clearly meant to discredit the whole Council and
thereby the Town in any effort of continuous improvement, change or
potential success;
'the true motive has become more than obvious'.

The good news is that this 'mud slinging' has failed! It simply is not
effective; the constant combative poking, negativity and critical style
towards individuals, in this case again senior staff, (often it is the
elected &/or the public) can only be for a personal agenda, almost a
vendetta, and does nothing to make Aurora a better place.

******************************

The Councillor continues along the same vein , vows to defend staff against me and encourages other Councillors to do the same.

I have no doubt he believes what he says. He is consistent.

A question occurs;why he is not prepared to shout it from the roof-tops when he is so confident of his rectitude and public appreciation of his good faith.

I think of the conference I attended in St.Johns, Newfoundland.

Staff went out from the University and asked people, in their homes and places where they gathered, what are the problems and how they could be fixed.

The film- makers returned later with videos for the participants to hear what they had said and examine their own logic.

In effect,people took their thoughts out, laid them on the table, to poke them and prod them and see how they stood up to the examination.

It's a Catholic idea. Examination of conscience.Impure thoughts and all that. The ritual becomes the habit of a lifetime. A particular genre of humour has been developed from the practice. We all recognise a Catholic when we hear one.

The University's project was so simple, it was brilliant.

Hundreds visit this Blog every day. Numbers continue to grow. I remain content I am making a contribution. It's not the one I would chose but it is the only one available to me.

I do not claim to be the single voice of the people. No-one can.

Mr. Wilson and his colleagues resolved from the beginning; no input from myself would be welcomed or permitted. They made no bones about it.

Time passed. Other Councillors were marginalised. The claque continued to hold the majority and added to it when former Councillor Grace Marsh resigned.

Four years is too long to sit quietly with hands folded in submission.Well,.Hell, four minutes is
entirely unlikely.

It is too long to spend being idle. You know what they say about the devil. I chiseled out my own role.

Councillor Wilson's bitter reaction is not surprising.

I recognize no obligation to uphold or explain decisions I strenuously oppose.

I do not hold staff responsible for decisions made by the Mayor and her following.

To allow them to pass unnoticed. To be forgotten by the time of the election.

No No No...Laddie

It's not going to happen.

If I were to copy the anonymous letter and Councillor Wilson's last e-mail and provide them to the two students invited to join this Council at the table to discover how this Council functions behind the scenes,

What impression would that make on fresh young minds, I wonder.

But I wont.

I will leave that up to the Councillor's own judgement

.

Sunday, 25 April 2010

The Question Has Been Asked

A citizen can file a complaint under the Code Of Conduct against a Member of Council

A staff person can file a complaint under the Code of Conduct against a Member of Council.

A Member of Council can file a complaint under the Code of Conduct against a Member of Council.

There is no provision for a Council to file a complaint against a Member of Council. Mr Mascarin the solicitor retained by Mayor Morris, pointed that out several times before six of them did it

See How They Run

The following is an exert from a Sunday Toronto Star report of a Mayoralty debate that took place yesterday. An issue was the sale of Toronto Hydro. Front runner candidate George Smitherman is opposed.

**********************************************
They’ve seen what happens when we lose control of public assets like we did with Highway 407,” he elaborated in a brief interview after the debate.

In February, a freedom of information request turned up the fact that after selling its street lights to Toronto Hydro in 2005 to raise $60 million, the city of Toronto will pay more than $420 million over the next 30 years to rent the lights back
********************************************************
Let's consider for a moment that information in the context of a Mayoralty debate:

Obviously Toronto owns Toronto Hydro.

A few years ago, the city sold the street lights to Toronto Hydro for $60 million dollars. They needed the money and the street lights were a mess.

In effect, they sold the lights to themselves.They took money out of one pocket and put it into another.

Then, in the story without attribution, the point is made that over thirty years it will cost $420million to rent them back.

Quick now, how much is that a year?

So the city will pay themselves all that money to rent their own lights back from themselves.

The lights on the other hand will show up in Toronto Hydro's books as assets. If Toronto Hydro is sold, assets create value.

So Toronto could get the money for the same lights twice..

Unless the lights have been replaced with newer lights. Then the city could get new lights back for the price they paid for the old lights, if they didn't sell the lights with Hydro.

Are we all following the logic?

What if Toronto got enough for Toronto Hydro to clear off all their debts.

Why are Mayoralty candidates talking sale of Hydro without referring to value and what could be done with the money.

How much transit would it buy?

Would they stop looking for innovative taxes like a toll on the Don Valley Parkway, to avoid raising the property tax and boasting about Toronto having the lowest taxes in the GTA.

Smitherman refers to the Province's sale of the 407.

What about it?

None of the other candidates it seems, referred to the Province, ruminating publicly about assets they might sell, like the Liquor Control Board of Ontario. to reduce their deficit.

GTA residents need to pay attention to Toronto's Mayoralty race. Smitherman is the front runner.

How much influence would he have convincing his former boss to unload more of Toronto's costs on to taxpayers in the rest of the GTA.

It's been done before.

And who do we have in York Region likely to put up a fight against that?

One Of The Good Things

and not the least of them, is Blog does not use paper.If a post is read every day by a couple of hundred people and not a single page of paper has been used that must be a good thing. Think of all the paper not printed, stapled,collated or circulated that doesn't need to be collected, re-cycled, pulped or take up space in a landfill site

Last week's Council in Committee agenda had 203 pages.

A report from the Director of Infrastructure and Environmental Services on new speed limits on Regional Roads had a twenty-two page regional report, complete with tables, already circulated at the region, attached to it.

Last time I asked, we were circulating thirty six copies of agendas. We added two more for students who don't attend council-in -committee meetings and even if they did, would be unlikely to read a twenty two page regional report complete with tables while attempting to follow discussion at the table.

In the same agenda ,we had a copy of a report circulated on- line to all Councillors from the Ontario Association of Municipalities. It had thirty-three pages of print, including cover and content pages. It was down-loaded and copied and circulated to all members of Council and sundry others to a total of probably forty, at the request of Councillor Gaertner.

It was entitled a Joint and Several Liability Paper submitted to the Province about the hardship of municipalities becoming third parties in law suits because we are the ones with the money.

No reason was given for its inclusion in the agenda. I didn't stay to ask.

Councillor Gaertner is a founding member of the Town's Environmental Advisory Committee,which advised creating the position of Environmental Engineer within the Department of Public Works, now Department of Infrastructure and Environmental Services.

When I asked about return on investment of a hundred thousand dollars a year on the position, The answer was; "identifying environmental initiatives"

I ask during budget discussions each year ,which environmental initiatives have been identified?

The answer is; no answer. Just a glance of complete mystification cast in my direction.

**************************************************************************************

On Friday I received a lengthy e-mail from the Mayor, circulated to all Councillors except one, entitled "harassment". the mayor took me to task for "criticizing" a senior staff member.

I had inquired of reasons for advertising for Parking Control Officers.What did it cost? Were we adding to the complement? I did not re-call an increase in officers discussed during budget.

No we are not, was the answer. The jobs are contract positions and therefore it should not be assumed the best people are in the jobs.

I had done a little digging and determined two officers have done the job for ten and twelve years and two others five years apiece. The fifth officer works from October until May. The jobs are all part-time.No benefits are paid. No union representation.No job security.

A job with serious responsibilities done for minimal cost...one might say, cheap at the price.

The one job which has changed, very recently, is Manager of Bylaw Services. Also recently Bylaw Services have been transferred from jurisdiction of Town Clerk to Chief Building Official.

Human Resources has also recently been transferred from the Clerk's jurisdiction to the Treasurer's. Both have new long-winded titles.It was the Treasurer/Human Resources Director who responded to my inquiry.

It seems to me, when people have been doing a job as long as the parking control officers have, it is reasonable to assume it has been done properly.That's a sensitive job. If it were not being done properly and fairly, elected officials would certainly hear about it. Nobody...but nobody..likes getting a parking ticket.

I have had the temerity to say, I am unable to accept the rational for recruiting new parking control officers.

Heavens to Betsy!!!!!!

The Mayor says that is criticism of senior staff and harassment.

****************************************************************************

Within the last year, the position of Chief Financial Officer, now Human Resources Director as well, was filled without recruitment or a competition. Despite there is a Provincial Regulation which requires recruitment and a Town Policy setting out the process.

Council was informed of the interim appointment behind closed doors.

The position is statutory. Statutory officers must be appointed by Bylaw. Only Council has authority to pass Bylaws.

Ergo, only Council has authority to appoint.

The Bylaw was passed after the fact.

It happened again when the interim appointment was made permanent. The morning after the last Council Meeting in December of last year, Council was informed, by e-mail, along with all employees, the appointment of Treasurer/Human Resources Director had been made permanent.

Again without authority.

Again without the Bylaw.

Provincial law requires municipalities to have a Treasurer. We did not for several weeks.

******************************************************************************

Municipalities carry insurance against the possibility of loss of funds for whatever reason.

Everyone who owns a house or a vehicle quickly learns the significance of fine print in an insurance policy.

It occurs to me to wonder if our insurance indemnification protects us in the circumstances of a loss, if the legal process(recruitment) for filling the position of Town Treasurer/ Human Resources Director by competition,to ensure we have the best person for the job, has not been followed.

Thursday, 22 April 2010

Look Look I did it again

I wish to respond to your blog.

Firstly, the granting of a charitable tax receipt by the OHF does not mean there is a sale involved. A right of use can be considered a gift and attract a receipt. The nature and condition attached to the gift determines its nature.

The discussion about the town getting part of the property and letting OHF sell part did not emanate from the OHF, but rather the Town(See www.bryanmoir.ca)

Finally, as I said before, a thorough review by a competent solicitor hired by the town confirmed that Mrs. Bartley-Smith intentions were to preserve this property. I concur with that view and even suggested that a court decide the issue, which OHF were not interested in.

Does not the fact the OHF is interested in a custodial agreement fly in the face of their position that they can do with the property what they want?

*******************

The foregoing is a comment to my post about the Ann Bartley Smith lands and Ontario Heritage Trust.

There's a reference to Bryan Moir who was a candidate in the last election.He was never a Councillor so, wherever he is now, he was never in a position to speak with certainty about the town's actions.

His web site references a letter in which he claims Ann Bartley Smith put a curse on the land. and suggests she and her husband are buried there.

He also claims to have been a founding member of S.W.A.T. So how much credence should we give to his statements?

There is also a contradiction in the claim, the town proposed development, while at the same time retaining a lawyer to confirm Ann Bartley Smith's intent was the opposite.

While I am not disagreeing the town obtained a legal opinion to opine on Ann Bartley Smith's intent, it still seems to me, if that's what she wanted to do with the land, that's what she would have done.

People do make straightforward bequests in wills, don't they?

And....wasn't that will challenged in court by the son? And upheld?

I'm just asking.

We have a custodial agreement with Heritage Trust of Ontario. It has been in place for years.
This week we have to try to change the mind of an official that a permeable product, very expensive, should be used to pave the parking lot at Shephard's Bush.We have a federal grant to pay for two-thirds of the project.Our share is $250,000.

Nobody should have any illusions that agreement gives us anything but responsibility for maintaining the property. At the time we were planning the artificial turf installation, Councillor Gaertner noticed a clause in the agreement that concerned her. It required permission for anything we do there. And further requires that anything we do, they can order us to undo at any time.

Councillor Gaertner successfully moved the clause be negotiated out of the agreement. Well,
that didn't happen.

No sir...A custodial agreement on the Ann Bartley Smith lands would do nothing but cost us money in exchange for Nothing, Nada, Zilch and Zero.

It's an illusion Mayor Morris is planning to point to, as an achievement in her re-election campaign.

Like the custodial agreement with the McLeod lands on Leslie Street owned by the Oak Ridges Moraine Trust. We get to pay four years back taxes and don't even get to take a walk in the woods for another six .

Like the Promenade Consultant Study which the Mayor claims is a greater investment than any Council has ever "invested", is, as we speak, restoring the downtown core to a vibrant commercial centre.

Smoke and Mirrors. Smoke and Mirrors.