"Cowardice asks the question...is it safe? Expediency asks the question...is it politic? Vanity asks the question...is it popular? But conscience asks the question...is it right? And there comes a time when one must take a position that is neither safe, nor politic, nor popular but one must take it because it is right." ~Dr. Martin Luther King

Monday 17 January 2011

Things I Cannot Explain

because I don't understand them myself. People in my age and income group are unlikely to be spending a fraction of $124,208 annually. Another chart presented at the budget session at the week-end orientation showed the average household income was $144K a year.

RTB wants to see the figures to help him understand.

Aging in Aurora is the fastest growing group . Actually that's a silly statement I just made. All of the people in Aurora are aging.Just like in every other place. We all grow old one day at a time.

Other things happen as well. Families break up. People become ill. Sometimes they don't get better. People lose jobs . If they don't have well-paid public service positions,they do not have protections against life's potential difficulties.

I don't think the figures helped to explain anything. Income for people at the basic Canada pension level is approximately $13,000.a year. Annual expenditures are hardly likely to be $124,208. There won't be children in the house. No $22.361. to pay for shelter. No child care costs. Nor $14,554.for transportation.Not even $15,529 for "other" expenses.

They won't be spending $11,621. on recreation and education. Or $39,809. on taxes and securities. I don't even know what that reference to securities is about.

I have no idea how the estimates were derived. So I can give no guarantee as to accuracy or relevance.

I know a person working in Canadian Tire, considered good employers in the retail industry because they provide benefits, are likely to have take-home pay of around $20,000.annually. That bracket pays the greatest share of income taxes because there are more of them. Both parents working would provide annual income of $40K.

A single mother working with dependent children would have earnings of $20K.

We talked about the average income and expenditure and the percentage of people with university degrees and graphs establishing the population of Aurora are well educated, well heeled and spend a high level of income on non-essentials.

We established there is no economic hardship in Aurora. Everybody is well able to pay whatever taxes we impose.Then we talked about how a budget is constructed.

There was some give and take on the subject.

RTB thinks it's silly to think about free use of swimming and skating facilities.

I grew up by the seaside. Warm summer days were spent at the shore.It didn't cost anything at all. We didn't always have bathing suits. The bottom half of our underwear often had to suffice.

The sea,the sun, sand dunes and sea shells, creatures in rock pools,hard sand when the tide went out, sometimes smooth sometimes with hard ridges, where soon hundreds of sand worm castings appeared as if by magic. It built great castles,and holes that held until the tide came back in and flooded them. If we didn't fill them with pails first. Scuttling crabs racing about, the waves ,the wind.no watches, no clock to tell the time.

The walk home that took us past the harbour and boats being loaded with coal and bricks and lumber from railroad cars and the dredger that kept the harbour mouth from silting up were all on one side of the road.

On the other,houses and shops in building hundreds of years old,still in use. The Ship Inn that was Rab Burns favourite pub when he was seventeen years old and a womaniser and a roustabout and living in Irvine.

His life already half over although he didn't know it and I just typed in Aurora for Irvine and had to correct it.

Towering behind the street was a great heap called the Blue Billie. There was blasting every day at noon for shale needed for construction... I suppose.It's not there any more. They changed the landscape.

The shore was always the place to be on sunny days. Some kids had mothers with them. I was with my sister Kathleen,two years my elder.

On rainy days, we played cards or guessing games in the lobby leading to our homes. Outside we played hide and seek and Leave a' and guessing and running games at the window of the wee sweety shop in the building next door. We climbed lamp posts when it was dark and gathered in the circle of light to tell ghost stories and scare ourselves half to death or silly rude jokes that had us collapsing in giggles with the sinfulness of it.

There were always crowds of kids. And chalk and a peever to play beds. Spinning tops, marbles,skipping ropes and balls to bounce against the walls. There were chestnuts hardened and pierced to draw a string through, Everybody didn't have these things. so turns were taken so that everybody could play but skills were not even.

There were dozens of games to be played with a ball. A rope game had two people
turning the rope and a line-up of kids waiting their turn to jump in and skip to a dozen different songs sung in chorus by the group.

There were many places to play.The drying green,the yard with the hard packed earth surrounded by the coal cellars and the wash-house in the corner that backed on to the communal lavatory. Between back yards were walls with round slippery tops to keep kids from climbing over. We walked on them with arms outstretched for balance and sometimes teeter and fall to the ground.

The lavatory had a stone floor. It was so old, the stone was worn to a hollow where thousands of feet had rested over hundreds of years. The wood door, with a hole in the middle big enough for a person's arm, probably started as a knot hole, was stuffed with newspaper. The door was held closed by a large boulder that had to be pushed into place. Easier for some than others.

Well...didn't I get off topic. I was saying I would like families to have free access to leisure swimming and skating programs. I wasn't proposing it. But I tell you what...If I were the solitary authority in our town, I would be looking for ways and means... and I fully understand why the city does it.

Children learn many worthwhile life skills through play with others of varying ages. If they don't get that opportunity and they are left out, they learn other things.

6 comments:

Anonymous said...

That's an interesting statement:

"We established there is no economic hardship in Aurora."

How was that derived? A little futher explanation may be necessary on that statement.

Just because Aurora may have a high average household income doesn't preclude it from having citizens with no economic hardship. If we follow that line then the previous council's statement that Aurora doesn't need affordable housing holds true and perhaps the local food bank is not needed. Whether you are a homeowner or not, I believe Aurora is an expensive place to live. Apartment rents are on par with Toronto and there's not many options. The people you speak of in working in retail in Aurora soon won't be able to live here and perhaps they already don't and have to commute from outside. I am sure there are people who bought in Aurora, 5,10,15 or 20 years ago who would not be able to afford to buy in Aurora today.

Robert the Bruce said...

Perhaps my question was not clear enough....

Can you provide more details as to this statement?

Statistics provided at the orientation,showed the average family expenditure in Aurora is $124,208.

Are you talking about all expeditures? Over what period of time? I'd like to understand what this number is.


If the Town staff are throwing around numbers like this to council in order to help them understand the budget process, I would EXPECT the council members to understand what and where the figure comes from - otherwise, how can effective budget control be achieved?

So, my question was an explanation of what this $124,000 figure is comprised? Is this all expenditures (food, clothing, utilities, etc)?

====

I re-read my initial comment and I never said that free skating or swimming was "silly". You should not put words into my mouth. You made a comment that the "have-nots" of this town were subsidizing the "haves" for these activities. You used this a justification to not charge anyone. I feel that if the Town is offering a service, those that use the service should pay for it. Why should someone who never skates pay the tax increase so that someone else can?

Fuimus

Elizabeth Bishenden said...

I am thinking only of skating facilities for this comment.

The Town of Aurora has at least four outdoor rinks. They seem to be mainly used for shinny, especially in the evening. (Though I have never had trouble finding a way to enjoy a pleasure skate while others play hockey.)

Yesterday my husband and sons were at Machell Park for about an hour and a half. They played shinny with some local folks, as well as some young men who had come from Bradford and Newmarket. Neither of those municipalities has outdoor rink facilities.

The outdoor rinks provide the perfect unstructured kind of play that our kids need for many reasons, and the use is free to anyone, regardless of their financial means.

(Hmmm... much like the Public Library... but I digress...)

Paul Sesto said...

I too have enjoyed being on the outdoor ice with my son. A couple of weeks ago I meet someone from Newmarket who was getting back into skating condition for a family get together of shinny. He said that it's great to be able to come to Aurora to skate outside as Newmarket doesn't make any outdoor rinks due to insurance and public liability reasons. Whether that is the reason or not who knows, but it's great that Aurora has the outdoor ice.

Goodie Two Shoes said...

Newmarket has one outdoor ice surface. It is fenced off because it is made on top of the tennis courts. It gets cleaned with a zamboni and it is a pay per use facility and I think it is only open in the evening. No free outdoor ice in Newmarket! You want it you pay for it. You would never find a game of shinny going on!

Jim Tree said...

Great comments on the outdoor rinks, Can't really comment on what others do, But I can tell you that Aurora has been in the business of providing outdoor natural ice since the early
1960s,thanks to the Father of Aurora's Parks, Norm Weller , and of course, Mother Nature. I can also tell you that the parks staff who make and maintain the ice take a huge amount of pride in their work and in keeping this great Canadian tradition alive, As a kid growing up in this Town I have great memories of the hours spent on the rink in our neighborhood. We could hardly wait for the Rink to reappear each winter , but it never failed to appear. Its sometimes difficult to place a value to the community on something as casual and unstructured as an outdoor skating rink, but the comments of your readers are quite telling.