"Cowardice asks the question...is it safe? Expediency asks the question...is it politic? Vanity asks the question...is it popular? But conscience asks the question...is it right? And there comes a time when one must take a position that is neither safe, nor politic, nor popular but one must take it because it is right." ~Dr. Martin Luther King

Tuesday 15 March 2011

The Saga Of A Lease

A question and answer that came up at the last budget meeting deserves to be expanded. 

In the course of  budget discussion, we had finally reached the town's revenue table. I noticed  rent for the hydro building was not on the list. The figure understood is $139K

I asked about that.

The treasurer responded that revenue was in  Public Works Department budget. But there was none.  Rent had not been paid until February and there had been expenditures.

You could say the answer  took me back a bit. I asked for it to be repeated. 

Residents may recall the triumphant announcement made  close to the election,about the great success of leasing the hydro building to the Department of National Defence,

There  was a glowing media release and  commendations  to the Chief Administrative Officer who concluded the lease.

The Mayor  referred to it in her speech at the all-candidates meeting she attended.

You may also recall I  was distinctly underwhelmed by the announcement. Considering the value of the property, I felt the rent was peanuts. The fact no jobs would derive from the deal made the prospect even less appealing.

The deal was being pushed through while an election was in process. I was supicious  of the motive.
I went so far as to call the Honorable  M.P. Lois Brown and seek her  services to delay the Minister's signature on the lease.

The Mayor commented in a council meeting,  it would be a place for "the kiddies" at the week-ends.

The building had been  used by the Parks Department for the previous four years. At one point I understood from  Bob Panizza, our thrice- removed municipal clerk , the space was being used  to store  artifacts.

A century barn which  had been dismantled ,board by board, nail by nail, was stored carefully indoors in  part of the building.

It was an extraordinarily fine building with an excellent yard completely secured by fence and power.
Parking lot. Landscaped. Illuminated.  It had housed twenty-nine employees when hydro was in place.
If I re-call correctly it had potential of $69K in assessment and millions as a capital asset,  

My preference was to sell it from the day hydro vacated . Restore opportunity for twenty- nine
unemployed  to become employed. Increase the town's revenue base. Realise millions from  the sale.  Decrease the tax rate.

It never happened . For four years the decision was pending. Then all of a sudden, the building was tied up in a lease  producing  none of  the above advantages.

It was said the deal  protected  our relations with the Queen's York Rangers .

There was never  an indication  our relationship with the Rangers needed any help. .

Two weeks after the lease was announced, at the time of the election  and after I spoke to M.P. Brown, the former Mayor circulated an e-mail with the good news, the  Minister of National Defence had signed the lease.

After that  there was work going on in the building. $100K , our money, was being spent on a sprinkler system.

The barn board artifacts so carefully stored were transported  equally carefully to the works yard and left out in the snow and rain.

Time went by. No sign of occupation of the  building.

Last week, we learned  rent did not begin until February. .

I requested a copy of the lease. At this point  I understand  I may not  receive said copy.

Legal documents are signed by the Mayor and  Clerk. The Chief Administrative Officer was credited for negotiating the lease. The town's legal department would be responsible for  writing the lease.

Therefore,  numbers of people  have had access to the lease and  its details.

Yet an elected  representative of   owners of the building has been denied access to the lease.

I await to be advised of the refusal  in writing before determining next steps.

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

Possibly you could also inquire about whether we can cancel the lease and what the penalties would be to do so

Anonymous said...

Who's a big wheel with the Queen's York Rangers?
Phyllis Morris' friend Chris Ballard

Anonymous said...

To the two anonymous posters - or are they the same, the times are so close....

1. Why would you cancel a lease. The building has not been used since the Powerstream sale? At lease now it is getting used and there is some sort of revenue coming in.

2. I beleive the QYR are the militia unit. The lease to DND was it not for the cadets? Put your tinfoil hat on if you think that Ballard is a big wheel with the QYR. Regardless, even if Ballard was in the CIC, who cares.